Dr. Ryan Sultan, an Assistant Professor at Columbia University, discusses the evolutionary underpinnings of ADHD, challenging the stigma associated with it. He explores how ADHD traits may have been advantageous in pre-industrial societies and the importance of viewing them through a holistic lens. The conversation dives into the neurobiological aspects and the need for a nuanced approach to managing ADHD, especially when considering its interplay with anxiety and mood disorders. Sultan emphasizes the value of neurodiversity in enhancing teamwork and creativity.
ADHD traits, viewed through an evolutionary lens, highlight how impulsivity and hyper-focus may have benefited early humans in survival situations.
Recognizing the high rates of comorbidity among individuals with ADHD underscores the importance of a comprehensive treatment approach that addresses both ADHD and accompanying conditions.
Deep dives
The Evolutionary Basis of ADHD
The concept of evolutionary psychiatry emphasizes the idea that ADHD traits may have had adaptive functions in ancestral environments, serving a purpose rather than being viewed solely as disorders. ADHD traits, such as impulsivity and hyper-focus, could have been advantageous for early humans in situations like hunting and exploring unknown territories. This evolutionary perspective encourages a shift away from labeling ADHD as purely a dysfunction, suggesting instead that these characteristics can provide unique strengths in specific contexts. By understanding ADHD through an evolutionary lens, individuals may better grasp the potential benefits of their traits in modern society.
Substance Use and Risk Factors
Individuals with ADHD often experience higher rates of comorbidity with other conditions, such as mood disorders and substance use, greatly impacting their overall mental health management. These additional challenges can exacerbate ADHD symptoms, leading to emotional struggles and poor self-esteem over time. The discussion highlights that addressing underlying or accompanying disorders is crucial in order to improve treatment outcomes and overall well-being for those with ADHD. Recognizing these comorbidities allows for a more comprehensive approach to care, focusing on individual strengths while addressing weaknesses.
Neurodiversity and Collaborative Strengths
Neurodiversity advocates for recognizing the value of various cognitive styles within society, showing that diverse thinking—inclusive of ADHD perspectives—can enhance community problem-solving and creativity. ADHD traits can facilitate innovation and spontaneous solutions, especially in environments that require adaptability and quick thinking. By fostering collaboration among individuals with differing cognitive abilities, communities can experience greater success and resilience in overcoming challenges. This approach encourages a collective effort to harness each individual's unique strengths for the benefit of the group.
The Importance of a Multi-Modal Treatment Approach
A multi-modal approach to treating ADHD is essential for achieving the best outcomes, integrating various methods such as medication, therapy, and environmental adjustments. Such a strategy recognizes that no single solution will suffice, and that combining different treatments can effectively address the diverse needs of individuals with ADHD. Support systems, like therapy or coaching, play a critical role in providing individuals with the tools to manage their symptoms and thrive. By emphasizing collaboration and adaptation, this treatment model can help individuals feel more empowered in their journeys toward better mental health.
Today, I’m talking with Dr. Ryan Sultan, a distinguished psychiatrist specializing in ADHD, anxiety, depression, and substance use disorders. He serves as an Assistant Professor of Clinical Psychiatry at Columbia University Irving Medical Center and the New York State Psychiatric Institute. Dr. Sultan is a Senior Psychiatrist at Integrative Psych.
And he has also been exploring the evolutionary basis for ADHD. Now, let’s get to a few things up front here because often when I hear about evolution and ADHD, I know I’m about to hear something about ADHD as a superpower.
That’s not what this conversation is about today. While we will be looking at how ADHD traits might have been useful in a pre-industrial world and why natural selection didn’t weed out our distractible, impulsive brains, the focus is more on how those brains thrived within society instead of looking at them in isolation. This means that our conversation mostly focuses on how these ADHD traits work in conjunction within society rather than trying to view them either negatively or positively. And then we also get into how understanding this evolutionary basis for ADHD can help us understand better ways of managing and treating ADHD.
Regarding the evolutionary basis of ADHD, avoid thinking of it in terms of better or worse and instead try to see how ADHD traits can serve the community as a whole.
With that lens in mind, the impulsivity, novelty-seeking, and hyper-focus of ADHD brains could have been advantages in early human societies, especially for hunting, exploring, and problem-solving in unpredictable environments. With the opposite from the structured, repetitive, sit-still-and-focus world we live in today giving us more difficulties because it wasn’t “designed” with the ADHD brain in mind.
Neurodiversity can benefit everyone. Societies thrive on diverse thinking styles. ADHD brains bring creativity, spontaneity, and out-of-the-box problem-solving, which can be a huge asset when properly supported. We’re better when we work together.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode