Zongyuan Zoe Liu, Maurice R. Greenberg fellow for China studies, talks about China's economic downturn, including the decline in economic growth, challenges with youth unemployment and skill set mismatch, aging population, and the impact on power dynamics and nationalism. The podcast also discusses the implications of the economic downturn on foreign policy choices, including the risks of an echo chamber effect and challenges in delinking issues in the Chinese reaction to the Biden administration initiatives.
China's economic downturn is a result of various factors including slow economic growth and an aging population.
The United States must set clear boundaries on off-limit technologies and engage in innovative diplomacy with China.
Deep dives
China's Economic Downturn
China's economy is experiencing a downturn, marked by declining manufacturing, decreased exports, and low foreign direct investment. The decline is not solely due to zero COVID policies or President Xi Jinping's leadership, but rather a combination of factors including a slowdown in economic growth, skill set mismatch, and reduced job opportunities. Chinese youth unemployment is a major concern, with unofficial estimates suggesting it could be as high as 45-50%. Additionally, China's rapidly aging population poses challenges for supporting their welfare and pension systems. While the economic slowdown may not threaten Xi's hold on power, it could strengthen nationalist sentiments and potentially lead to a more assertive foreign policy. Despite the challenges, China still has the capacity to invest heavily in its military and continues to have room for cooperation with the United States on various issues, such as climate change. However, the timing and willingness to engage in dialogues may be affected by factors like upcoming elections and uncertain political dynamics.
Swings in Policy and State Involvement
The Chinese economic downturn is primarily a result of swings in policies rather than increased state involvement in the economy. While Xi Jinping's ambitious agenda and changes in policies have contributed to the structural problems, the Chinese state has always been present in the economy. The focus should be on addressing swings in policies and providing clarity on off-limit technologies that can directly contribute to military capabilities. The United States should deliver a clear message to both American businesses and Chinese leaders, emphasizing that certain technologies should not be accessible to the People's Liberation Army. Innovative diplomacy, with separate agendas for sensitive and cooperative issues, could help facilitate meaningful discussions. The challenge lies in overcoming the reluctance of the Chinese government to compartmentalize conversations and their view that linking issues is necessary.
Foreign Policy Choices and Economic Concerns
The United States should carefully navigate its foreign policy choices amidst China's economic slowdown. Setting clear boundaries regarding off-limit technologies and being open to cooperative discussions on various issues is essential. However, China's current skepticism and focus on blaming others for economic problems create challenges in engaging in productive dialogue. The Chinese media environment is closed, limiting access to alternate perspectives. The slowing economy combined with concerns over state revenue and public confidence could lead to enhanced nationalism and belligerence. Recognizing the impact of swings in policies and economic trends, while separating them from issues related to military expansion, is crucial in formulating an effective approach to China's economic challenges.
Zongyuan Zoe Liu, the Maurice R. Greenberg fellow for China studies, sits down with James M. Lindsay to discuss the causes and consequences of China’s faltering economy.