Dr. Matthew Barrett, an expert on the Reformation, discusses the connection between the Reformers and the catholic church. They explore the narrative of the Reformation as a renewal and restoration, the importance of balancing Protestant principles and Catholic substance, and the influence of figures like Bernard of Clairvaux on John Calvin. They also discuss exhibiting catholicity within Protestantism and defining distinctions from Eastern Orthodoxy.
The Reformation was not a complete break from the Catholic Church, as the reformers sought to renew and retrieve the catholic and universal church.
The reformers defended their catholicity by engaging with the church fathers and medieval theologians, using their teachings to support their theological arguments.
Deep dives
The Reformation as Renewal and Retrieval of the Catholic Church
The podcast examines the Reformation and its relationship to the Catholic Church. It challenges the misconception that the Reformation was a complete break from the Church Catholic, arguing that the reformers sought to renew and retrieve the one holy Catholic and apostolic church. It highlights the reformers' efforts to demonstrate their catholicity and their engagement with the church fathers and medieval theologians. The podcast explores the theological and historical implications of the Reformation as renewal and the ongoing importance of understanding the Reformation in the context of catholic substance.
The Debate over the Catholicity of the Reformation
The podcast discusses the debate over the catholicity of the Reformation. It challenges the common misconception that the Reformation was a complete departure from the church Catholic. It explores how the reformers sought to demonstrate their continuity with the church universal and their use of patristic and medieval sources to support their theological arguments. The podcast emphasizes the reformers' efforts to defend their catholicity against accusations of novelty and heresy. It also addresses the influence of the oppositional narrative and the misconception that the Reformation was a total break from the church Catholic.
The Reformation as a Renewal of Theology
The podcast examines the Reformation as a theological renewal. It highlights the reformers' theological efforts to correct the soteriology and ecclesiology of the late medieval period. It underscores the influence of figures like Augustine, Bernard, and Anselm on the reformers and their retrieval of key theological concepts. The podcast emphasizes the reformers' engagement with the medieval tradition and their vision of renewing theology in continuity with the Church Catholic. It also addresses the misconceptions surrounding the relationship between the Reformation and modernity.
The Reformation as a Call for Protestant Orthodoxy and Catholic Substance
The podcast discusses the importance of Protestant orthodoxy and catholic substance in the context of the Reformation. It highlights the need for Protestants to engage with the church's historical and doctrinal orthodoxy. The podcast emphasizes the reformers' commitment to theological renewal within the framework of catholicity. It addresses the cautionary approach to retrieval theology, encouraging a balanced perspective that acknowledges the differences between Protestant traditions while focusing on core theological principles. The podcast emphasizes the importance of understanding the Protestant perspective in light of Catholic substance without undervaluing the significance of historical and theological diversity.
Was the Reformation really as much a break with what came before it as we are often led to believe? Dr. Matthew Barrett says the Reformers themselves thought not. In his substantial new book, he shows how strongly the Reformers sought to establish their connection with the catholic and universal church. Alastair, Derek, and Matt join Dr. Barrett for a lively and fruitful discussion on this episode of Mere Fidelity.
Full show notes at www.merefidelity.com.
Timestamps:
Repeat Guest [0:00]
14.7 lbs. [1:49]
How catholic was the Reformation? [4:36]
Reformation(s) Plural [15:50]
Baptists [22:20]
Precipitating Modernity [32:57]
Medieval VIPs [41:06]
Principles of Retrieval [48:49]
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode