

Mere Fidelity
Mere Fidelity
From the Mere Orthodoxy Podcast Network: The Podcast reflecting on God's Word and our world. Thoughtful weekly conversations about theology, the culture, and the church, hosted by Derek Rishmawy and Alastair Roberts. Featuring Andrew Wilson, Brad East, James Wood, and Joseph Minich.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Oct 8, 2025 • 1h 14min
Do You Need Penal Substitution?
Derek and Brad dive into the heated debates surrounding atonement, particularly penal substitution. They discuss how personal experiences and teaching can skew understanding. The conversation highlights its presence across various evangelical traditions and its implications for preaching. They examine the historical context and different emphases in church history, debating whether penal substitution is innovative or merely retrieved. Throughout, they stress the importance of clarity and charity in discussing God's justice and mercy.

Oct 1, 2025 • 42min
Replay: Thinking For Yourself
The hosts tackle the complex question of whether Christians should lean on their own judgment or the guidance of church authorities. They explore the importance of responsible belief and the role of pastors in shaping congregational thinking. Discussion includes the need for personal theological study and the risks of overly relying on church leaders. Collective reasoning is emphasized, encouraging communal discernment rather than individualism. The balance between submission and healthy disagreement is also a key theme, promoting respectful dialogue within the church.

26 snips
Sep 24, 2025 • 56min
Reflecting on Charlie Kirk
The hosts dive into the tragic assassination of Charlie Kirk, discussing its impact on society and the role of social media in shaping narratives. They reflect on the dangers of violence and the need for a Christ-centered response, emphasizing prayer and community. The conversation critiques the celebratory reactions to violence online, explores how meme culture dehumanizes, and warns against the risks of political polarization. They also highlight Augustine's teachings on justice and the importance of living out Christian values in times of chaos.

6 snips
Sep 17, 2025 • 51min
The Tabernacle, The Temple, and the Church
Dive into the significance of the tabernacle and temple in understanding God's presence among His people. Unpack the deep connections between these structures and Israel's kingship, as well as the fascinating transition of the church as the new temple. Explore the complexities of divine presence, from intimacy to awe, and reflect on how destruction and rebuilding shape our faith narrative. The conversation highlights the rich theological layers that inform our understanding of worship and community.

11 snips
Sep 8, 2025 • 47min
Are You Scared Of Ambition?
A lively discussion unfolds about 'holy ambition' in ministry, balancing personal aspirations with faithfulness to God. The hosts delve into the influence of social media on pastoral goals, highlighting how it can amplify vanity and fear of cancellation. They emphasize the necessity for pastors to seek God's approval rather than societal recognition. This thought-provoking conversation encourages dreaming big while staying rooted in faith, tackling the challenges of modern ministry head-on.

Sep 3, 2025 • 48min
Replay: What Difference Does A Doctrine of Creation Make?
The discussion dives into the doctrine of creation and its profound implications for believers. Questions about the reality of creation and the nature of worship spark engaging insights. The hosts explore how curiosity connects to a deeper understanding of God, emphasizing its importance. They also challenge the notion that worship is limited to specific moments, suggesting it can permeate daily life. Through thoughtful analysis, the conversation reveals connections between creation and human identity, inviting reflections on purpose and faith.

25 snips
Aug 27, 2025 • 60min
Two Cheers For Modernity!
The hosts dive into the ambivalent nature of modernity, debating its merits and pitfalls. They explore how advancements in technology and medicine have transformed lives, yet create challenges like personal alienation. Parenting pressures are discussed, revealing how the race for success can stifle freedom. The conversation shifts to identity, touching on modern insecurities and the need for community resilience, illustrated by an ark metaphor. Ultimately, they advocate for a thoughtful Christian engagement with modern changes.

11 snips
Aug 20, 2025 • 1h 7min
Are We Disenchanted? Should We Be Enchanted?
Delve into the enchanting themes of theology and culture as the hosts explore the modern sense of disenchantment. They reflect on the nuances of Charles Taylor’s thoughts and the implications of losing a sacramental imagination. The discussion weaves through dangers like superstition while highlighting the opportunities for faithful re-enchantment through Scripture and worship. Listeners are invited to find wonder in creation and recover joy through daily discipleship, asking crucial questions about spirituality in a rational world.

18 snips
Aug 13, 2025 • 1h 5min
Should I Stay Or Should I Go (From My Denomination)?
The conversation dives into the complexities of leaving and inhabiting religious traditions, spotlighting a recent shift from Baptist to Anglican. The hosts explore how denominational transitions affect personal relationships and ecclesiology. They emphasize the need for grace and gratitude when departing from one’s faith roots. Discussions also highlight the role of traditions in offering diverse viewpoints and the importance of respectful dialogue across differing beliefs, fostering understanding amid the fragility of modern denominational identities.

9 snips
Jul 23, 2025 • 53min
Can You Really Read The Bible Like That?!
Explore the fascinating balance between traditional and typological biblical interpretations. Hear discussions on how the apostles engaged with Scripture beyond original intent and the potential pitfalls of subjective readings. Dive into how narrative connections, like those between Joseph and Jesus, enrich our understanding. Delve into creative approaches to Scripture, likening interpretation to performance art or video games. The conversation also emphasizes the need for community engagement and deeper dialogue to uncover the Bible's diverse meanings.