In this episode, American writer David Foster Wallace discusses his experiences following John McCain's campaign for the Republican presidential nomination in 2000. The podcast explores McCain's distinctive political style and its implications for American democracy. It also highlights the role of technology in Donald Trump's successful 2016 campaign and delves into Wallace's contrasting views on McCain and Trump's authenticity. The episode concludes by discussing the parallels between Trump's rise to power and the narrative described by Wallace, including themes of populism, technological shifts, and media coverage.
The paradox of John McCain's candidacy: being authentic and genuine may not be enough for voters if there are significant policy differences.
The rise of social media and technology has changed the political landscape, allowing for a different kind of populism that is less controllable by traditional establishment forces.
Deep dives
John McCain as a Non-Packaged Candidate
This podcast episode discusses David Foster Wallace's essay on John McCain's presidential campaign in 2000. McCain was seen as a non-packaged candidate, displaying genuine human qualities that attracted young people and independents. Despite holding conservative views, his authenticity and sarcastic charm appealed to voters who were disillusioned with conventional politicians.
The Paradox of McCain's Candidacy
Foster Wallace explores the paradox of McCain's candidacy. Although he came across as a sincere and human politician, he had conservative views that would typically turn off younger voters. Foster Wallace questions whether it is enough for a candidate to be authentic and whether voters can overlook policy differences in favor of someone who seems genuine.
Changes in Technology and Politics
The podcast highlights how technology played a role in changing the political landscape. In the 2000 campaign, hardware was still central, with journalists relying on equipment and physical connections. However, by 2016, the rise of social media and platforms like Twitter allowed candidates like Donald Trump to control the narrative and bypass traditional gatekeepers. This shift in technology gave rise to a different kind of populism that was less controllable by establishment forces.
The Legacy of McCain and Trump
The podcast discusses what happened after McCain's 2000 campaign and the emergence of Sarah Palin as his running mate. Despite the initial excitement, McCain ultimately lost the presidency in 2008. However, the essay suggests that Palin's populism foreshadowed the rise of Donald Trump in 2016. Unlike McCain, Trump embraced his role as a salesman and reveled in his authenticity, even if it meant being uninformed or disregarding conventional political wisdom.
Episode 10 in our series on the great essays is about David Foster Wallace’s ‘Up, Simba!’, which describes his experiences following the doomed campaign of John McCain for the Republican presidential nomination in 2000. Wallace believed that McCain’s distinctive political style revealed some hard truths about American democracy. Was he right? What did he miss? And how do those truths look now in the age of Trump?
‘The risk Wallace takes is to guess he is not the only "obscenely well-educated", curiously lost and empty white boy out there; that his sadness is also the experience of a whole historical moment.’
‘It was the essayists who were left to cope with his almost radioactive influence. He produced a great deal of excellent writing, the majority of it not his own.’