Delve into the intriguing dynamics of recessions and how they unfold over time. Discover the pivotal role hiring plays in economic downturns, highlighting that a decline in job creation can foreshadow a recession more than layoffs. Uncover the crucial missing ingredient that transforms a mere recession into a full-blown depression. Historical patterns provide insights into how 2024 may fit into this ongoing economic narrative.
The critical factor distinguishing a recession from a mere economic downturn is the noticeable slowdown in hiring rather than an increase in layoffs.
Research indicates that the decline in hiring significantly impacts the likelihood of job finding, exacerbating economic instability during downturns.
Deep dives
The Role of Hiring in Economic Downturns
The difference between a typical downturn and a recession lies in hiring patterns rather than layoffs. While the public often associates job losses with economic contractions, the real indicator of impending recession is the slowdown in hiring. In many cases, such as the Great Recession, job cuts are a lagging indicator; for example, after job cuts ceased in 2010, the economic contraction continued. It is the lack of new hiring that triggers the transition from a downturn into a recession and potentially worsens the economic landscape into a depression.
Exploring Job Market Dynamics
Research indicates that the probability of finding a job significantly decreases during economic downturns, emphasizing the importance of hiring in understanding labor market trends. A key study by Robert Scheimer highlights that fluctuations in unemployment are largely driven by changes in the likelihood of finding new employment, rather than the frequency of layoffs. This means that when hiring slows down, it creates a concerning cycle where unemployed individuals cannot secure new jobs, leading to broader economic issues. The focus should be not just on job losses but on the overall hiring environment to accurately assess economic health.
Current Labor Market Indicators
Recent data reveals troubling signs in the labor market, with decreasing hiring rates and a falling labor force participation rate indicating economic weakness. Even as layoff rates remain low, the consistent decline in hiring signals an unhealthy labor market, reminiscent of previous economic downturns. For instance, trends from JOLTS data and continued claims demonstrate that without sufficient hiring, the economy is set for stagnation rather than recovery. The ongoing patterns underscore the notion that hiring is essential to economic stability, and its absence is a precursor to recessionary conditions.
Recessions are a process and what past episodes all have in common is one key ingredient. Rather, one element that comes up missing every time. This critical factor doesn't just end up being the difference between downturn and full-blown contraction, it also turns a recession into a depression. And we've got the data for it plus how 2024 fits into the pattern.
Eurodollar University's Money & Macro Analysis
Robert Shimer Reassessing the Ins and Outs of Unemployment https://home.uchicago.edu/shimer/wp/reassess.pdf