Becoming Something with Jonathan Pokluda Episode 349: The Proof for Christmas (feat. Lee Strobel)
9 snips
Dec 8, 2025 
Lee Strobel, a renowned Christian author and apologist, brings his investigative skills to the Christmas story. He discusses why he updated The Case for Christmas, revealing surprising historical insights. Strobel debunks common nativity myths, arguing that 'katalima' means 'guest room' rather than 'inn.' He explores December 25th's origins and the cultural practices repurposed by Christians. Finally, he shares a personal anecdote about how witnessing a family's faith during his journalism days transformed his understanding of Christmas.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Guest Room, Not An Inn
- The Greek word katalima likely means "guest room," not a commercial inn, shifting the nativity scene into a family home.
- Lee Strobel argues this explains the manger and animal presence without an innkeeper turning Mary away.
How December 25th Was Chosen
- December 25th likely arose from calculating Jesus' conception on March 25th and linking it to his death date.
- Early Christians used March 25th as both conception and crucifixion markers, producing the December 25th birth date.
Christmas As A Redeeming Counterpoint
- Early Christians repurposed pagan seasonal timing to offer a redemptive alternative to winter festivals.
- Strobel says Christmas was framed as a counterpoint to pagan debauchery around the winter solstice.
