Gender: A Wider Lens
198 - The Trans Inclusion Controversy That Took Over La Leche League with Helen Joyce & Marian Tompson
Episode guests
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- Marian Tompson's resignation from La Leche League underscores the tension between traditional breastfeeding practices and current gender inclusivity policies.
- The podcast emphasizes the unique biological aspects of breastfeeding that cannot be replicated by individuals who do not give birth.
- The discussion highlights the need for a nuanced dialogue that respects women's experiences while addressing contemporary gender identity issues in maternal care.
Deep dives
The Origins and Philosophy of La Leche League
La Leche League was founded in the 1950s by Marian Thompson and six other women in Chicago as a grassroots effort to support breastfeeding among mothers, who often lacked professional guidance on the subject. At a time when doctors discouraged breastfeeding, the group's philosophy centered on mother-to-mother support, recognizing women as experts in their own experiences. The organization quickly gained popularity, expanding to over 80 countries and becoming the oldest and largest breastfeeding support group worldwide. Its founding principle emphasized the importance of women helping other women navigate breastfeeding, based on personal experiences, creating a unique, empathetic community.
Controversial Changes in Inclusivity Policies
In recent years, La Leche League has made significant shifts in its inclusivity policies, allowing individuals who identify as men, including trans women, to participate in breastfeeding discussions and initiatives. This change has sparked controversy among the founder's original members and supporters, as it seemingly undermines the organization’s foundational focus on the mother-baby relationship. Instead of promoting breastfeeding as a distinctly female experience, the language has evolved to terms like 'human milk feeding,' which some argue dilutes the essence and importance of breastfeeding as a biological and gender-specific act. The shift reflects broader cultural debates about gender identity and women's roles, creating divisions among those who feel the mission of La Leche League has been compromised.
Marian Thompson's Resignation and Its Significance
Marian Thompson, one of the founding members of La Leche League, recently resigned in protest against the organization’s new inclusivity direction, viewing it as a betrayal of its original purpose. At 95 years old, she expressed deep concern over the implications of including men in the breastfeeding discourse, emphasizing that the essence of breastfeeding lies in the unique bond between mothers and their children. This resignation highlights a significant internal conflict within the organization, as long-time supporters grapple with the evolving narrative of motherhood and breastfeeding in light of contemporary gender discussions. Thompson’s departure raises questions about how the values of La Leche League can be upheld while adapting to modern societal changes.
The Biological Importance of Breastfeeding
The podcast discusses the critical biological components of breast milk, which are intricately designed to meet the specific needs of infants and are tailored depending on various factors, including time of day and the baby's health. Breastfeeding not only provides essential nutrients but also strengthens the immunological bond between mother and child, adapting to the infant's requirements in real-time. The conversation underscores the danger of undermining women’s biological role in nurturing their infants through breastfeeding, as men cannot replicate the intricate, evolved processes involved. There’s a strong call to recognize that breastfeeding is fundamentally about the mother's ability to nourish her child and not merely an act of providing liquid sustenance.
Navigating the Cultural Conversation Around Gender and Motherhood
The episode highlights the complexities surrounding motherhood, breastfeeding, and gender identity in contemporary society, raising questions about the societal implications of gender inclusivity initiatives. While advocating for a more inclusive dialogue, the hosts express concern over how some narratives may diminish the specialization and significance of women’s experiences in lactation. The discussion suggests that authentic conversations should encompass both the challenges faced by women seeking support in breastfeeding as well as the evolving views on gender, without compromising the foundational aspects of maternal care. Ultimately, it calls for a balanced approach that respects the historical significance of breastfeeding while encouraging open, thoughtful discussions about gender identity.
In this special episode, Sasha and Stella pass the mic to honorary guest host, journalist, author, and feminist campaigner, Helen Joyce, who interviews Marian Tompson, in connection with Joyce’s recent article about Marian in The Times, "Why I Quit the Breastfeeding Charity I Founded Over Trans Ideology".
Marian Tompson, along with six other mothers, founded the global breastfeeding support network, La Leche League, in 1956. In November 2024, Tompson resigned from both the organization and its Board of Directors, believing it had strayed from its original mission to support biological mothers in breastfeeding.
Helen’s conversation with Marian touches on the physiological intricacies of breastfeeding, the historical challenges women faced to maintain breastfeeding practices, and the broader implications of integrating transgender individuals into traditionally female-centered spaces like La Leche League. Together, they share a candid discussion exploring how biological realities, societal shifts, and ideological debates converge in today’s discourse on gender, motherhood, and breastfeeding.
For links and resources relevant to this episode, access the full show notes at https://www.widerlenspod.com/p/episode-198
Buy Our Book – When Kids Say They’re Trans: A Guide for Thoughtful Parents at https://whenkidssaytheyretrans.com/
Join Our Listener Community to Access Exclusive Content at https://www.widerlenspod.com/
Support the Show at https://www.widerlenspod.com/p/support-the-show
Join the conversation on YouTube at www.youtube.com/@widerlenspod
For more information about Sasha’s & Stella’s parent coaching membership groups, visit:
Sasha Ayad: https://sashaayad.com/parenting-coaching
Stella O’Malley: http://www.stellaomalley.com/parent-coaching
To learn more about our sponsors, visit:
Therapy First at https://www.therapyfirst.org/
Genspect at https://genspect.org/
This is a public episode. If you’d like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.widerlenspod.com/subscribe
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.widerlenspod.com/subscribe
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
