Best of the Spectator Coffee House Shots: who really runs No.10?
7 snips
Dec 6, 2025 In this discussion, Tom Baldwin, a journalist and biographer of Keir Starmer, and Tim Shipman, political editor at The Spectator, explore the nuances of Labour's strategy. They debate whether Starmer should shift left economically and how internal party dynamics impact voter perceptions. Baldwin critiques the obsession with 'super-advisers' that clouds Labour's message, while Shipman highlights Starmer's challenges in effectively communicating his values. The conversation also touches on the importance of personal storytelling in politics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Labour Losing Ground On The Left
- Since the start of the year Labour has lost more voters to parties on the left than to the right, accelerating after Zach Polanski took over the Greens.
- Tim Shipman argues this justifies a leftward economic tilt while keeping firm migration commitments to maximise overall votes.
Immigration Messaging Can Repel The Left
- Tom Baldwin cites academic research showing security-focused immigration messaging cost Labour votes to the left without winning back the right.
- He warns 'tough' framing on migration can backfire by pushing progressive voters away.
Shift Focus From Leaks To Delivery
- Reduce the focus on adviser infighting and leaks and shift attention to policy delivery that affects people’s lives.
- Tom Baldwin urges the government to emphasise tangible improvements in schools, hospitals and household costs instead of Westminster drama.
