The Real Science of Sport Podcast

Is the Credibility of Sports Science's Most Respected Journal Under Threat?

Nov 15, 2024

The podcast dives into the controversial stance of the British Journal of Sports Medicine regarding transgender athletes. It raises crucial questions about the journal's credibility amidst scientific debates. The discussion explores the ethical responsibilities of sports science publishing and the importance of maintaining rigorous standards. Viewpoints on gender performance are examined, shedding light on the complexities surrounding women's sports and the implications of inclusivity. Listeners will appreciate the nuanced approach to an increasingly polarized discussion.

01:10:02

Creator website

AI Summary

AI Chapters

Episode notes

Podcast summary created with Snipd AI

Quick takeaways

The British Journal of Sports Medicine's recent support for controversial narratives raises concerns about its commitment to scientific rigor and integrity.

The peer review process is crucial for maintaining research quality, yet worries persist regarding the expertise and objectivity of selected reviewers.

Disregarding biological differences in discussions about transgender athletes undermines fairness in women's sports, complicating the integrity of competitive events.

Deep dives

The Impact of the British Journal of Sports Medicine

The British Journal of Sports Medicine (BJSM) is a pivotal publication in the realm of sports science, valued for its influence and high impact factor among researchers. It functions as a platform for disseminating scientifically rigorous studies and fostering debate on contemporary issues within sports medicine. Recent developments indicate that the journal may be straying from its foundational purpose by endorsing controversial narratives without adequate scientific backing, particularly surrounding topics like transgender participation in sports. This risks compromising the journal’s integrity and the credibility of the research it publishes, leading many to question the reliability of its content as well as the broader implications for women's sports.

Intro

2min

The Ethics of Sports Science Publishing

12min

The Accessibility and Challenges of Scientific Publishing

3min

The Crucial Role of Credibility in Sports Science Publishing

4min

Navigating Gender and Sports Performance

17min

Exploring Gender Superiority in Sports: A Physiological Perspective

2min

Women in Sports: Equality, Inclusion, and Controversy

30min

Voicing Concerns in Sports Science: The Impact and Consequences

3min

At the recent British Association of Sports & Exercise Medicine (BAsem) conference, the world's most respected journal in sports science - the British Journal of Sports Medicine (BJSM) - openly promoted a presentation done on the trans issue by the author of the controversial book Open Play: The Case For Feminist Sport, Dr Sheree Bekker. In the presentation, Bekker challenges the ideas around transgender sporting advantage despite persuasive scientific evidence to the contrary, raising the question of whether the BJSM has failed in its mandate to support robust scientific content. The team break down what the BJSM's role in sports science should be, analyse some of the outlandish statements made in the presentation and discuss the implications of what happens if credibility is lost.

SHOW NOTES:

The tweet by the BJSM on the presentation done by Dr Bekker

The photo claiming to show the TWSA and Feminist Approach to the gender debate

Dr Sheree Bekker's website

A link to the BJSM website

Ross's X thread reacting to the presentation

Get bonus content on Patreon

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.