This Means War
What if the deep battle doesn’t matter?
Sep 14, 2023
Franz-Stefan Gady, a commentator on modern warfare and maneuver theory, challenges the conventional wisdom surrounding deep battle strategies in military conflict. He questions whether adversaries are even structured for systems warfare as envisioned by Western militaries. The discussion delves into the complexities of Ukraine's tactics, the crucial role of engineering in modern warfare, and historical lessons from the Wehrmacht's strategies during WWII. Gady advocates for a reevaluation of current doctrines to better prepare future military leaders.
34:57
Episode guests
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- The effectiveness of deep battle strategies in modern warfare is questioned, highlighting the need for adaptability to evolving battlefield dynamics.
- The resurgence of engineering tactics emphasizes the importance of defensive measures, complicating traditional maneuver warfare in contemporary conflicts.
Deep dives
The Maneuver Debate in Ukraine
The ongoing conflict in Ukraine has sparked significant discussion around the efficacy of maneuver warfare versus attritional tactics. Initial attempts by Ukrainian forces reflected a transition towards Western military principles but ultimately struggled against entrenched Russian defenses. Reports indicate the swift shift to a more attritional approach as Ukrainian forces faced formidable resistance, leading many to question the critiques directed at their general staff regarding maneuver strategies. This highlights the complex nature of modern warfare, where maneuvering without the necessary groundwork and understanding of battlefield dynamics is insufficient for success.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
