Casefile True Crime Case 274: Benjamin Amato
Mar 2, 2024
Investigating the suspicious death of Benjamin Amato, initially believed to be an accident but revealed to be murder. Clues suggest a brutal attack on Ben, with suspects Cheryl and Chad explored. Intricate plots, proposed murder schemes, and unexpected twists. Illuminating Ben's financial revelations and motives behind his murder. Trial of Cheryl Kunkle, emotional testimonies, doubts, and guilty verdict. Unsolved double homicide in Easy Street, unresolved case with lingering questions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Murder Not Accident
- Benjamin Amato's death was initially suspected as an accident but later confirmed as a murder involving pepper spray and blunt force trauma.
- The presence of a boot print at the crime scene was crucial evidence indicating foul play, not an accident or suicide.
Custody Dispute Catalyst
- Cheryl Kunkle and Benjamin Amato's relationship deteriorated after she became pregnant and he refused involvement fearing mental health risks.
- Their custody dispute escalated, with Cheryl denying Ben contact with their biological son, deepening the conflict.
Fear of Murder Expressed
- Benjamin Amato feared for his life, expressing to his lawyer that if he were found dead, Cheryl would be responsible.
- This showed the extreme tension and threats surrounding the custody battle before his murder.