David Goodhart, author of The Care Dilemma, examines the clash between gender equality and caregiving, advocating for stronger family ties. Kathryn Faulke shares heartfelt stories from her experiences as a frontline carer, revealing the human side of adult social care. Anna Coote emphasizes systemic changes needed in public health policy to uplift both caregivers and those they support. Together, they explore the current care crisis, the importance of community, and innovative solutions for a more equitable care system.
The crisis in adult social care reflects years of government neglect, highlighting the urgent need for substantial investment and systemic support.
Gender disparities in care work devalue the profession, necessitating reforms to raise its status and ensure fair compensation for caregivers.
Deep dives
The Care Crisis and Its Impact on Society
The discussion highlights the fragility of care systems, primarily due to years of neglect from successive governments. Acknowledging that many care services have declined since 2010 due to austerity measures, it emphasizes the need for substantial investment in care, as it plays a crucial role in societal well-being. The speakers point out the misconception that individuals can manage their care independently without systemic support, illustrating how this oversight has led to significant societal challenges. By focusing on care as a vital part of the economy, they argue for reevaluating its importance in policy implementation.
The Gender Dynamics of Care Work
The conversation delves into the gender disparities that persist within care work, particularly the societal perception of care as a women's role. This devaluation contributes not only to low wages but also to a lack of respect for the profession as a whole. By examining the impact of women entering the workforce, the speakers discuss how this shift has strained familial relationships and care responsibilities. They stress the importance of raising the status of care work to ensure it is recognized and valued, rather than viewed as an obligation connected to gender stereotypes.
Proposed Solutions for Improving Care Systems
Suggestions for reforming care systems include the implementation of a home care allowance and the need for a systemic overhaul that recognizes the diverse forms of families. Advocates propose that funding allocated to childcare could also be distributed directly to families to increase their options, enabling parents to choose between working or staying home. The discussion also touches on making care work more appealing through better pay and professional recognition, addressing the recruitment crisis faced in the sector. Moreover, emphasizing a coordinated approach across sectors could better integrate care services, ultimately benefiting those in need.
The Value of Frontline Care Workers
The insights from frontline workers illustrate the deeply personal and emotional intricacies of care work, emphasizing that it is far more than a series of tasks. Care work is portrayed as a complex blend of skills, including emotional intelligence, communication, and practical care abilities. By sharing poignant examples from their experiences, care workers reveal the inherent value in their role and the connections formed with those they care for. This narrative shift is crucial in changing public perception and elevating the status of care work as a professional and essential service within society.
Adam Rutherford gets to grips with the crisis in adult social care and asks, whose responsibility is it to fix it?
David Goodhart, from the Policy Exchange think tank, writes about the huge changes that have been wrought on family life over the past 60 years and how they have impacted the way in which we live and care for each other. In his new book, The Care Dilemma, he argues that we are in desperate need of a new policy settlement that not only supports gender equality, but also recognises the importance of strong family and community bonds, and the traditional role women have played as carers.
Bringing us her own personal story from the frontline of adult social care is Kathryn Faulke. She worked for years in a senior role at the NHS and then became a home care worker. In Every Kind of People she tells the stories of individuals who are part of the system, the cared-for and the carers, and shows how these issues affect us all. This is a story about real lives and real people, revealing the challenges, and the benefits, of working with some of the most vulnerable members of society. Every Kind of People will be Radio 4's Book of the Week, starting on Monday 28th October.
So how can we improve the lives of those who require care and also support the carers themselves? Anna Coote is Principal Fellow at the New Economics Foundation and has written extensively on public health policy, public involvement and gender and equality. She believes in taking practical action to change the way we work and value time and believes in our ability to build a fairer and more sustainable social security system – both for ourselves and for future generations.
Producer: Natalia Fernandez
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode