In this conversation, Michael and Caleb discuss Ryan Holiday's book The Obstacle Is the Way. They cover the good, bad, and provocative. Both argue that it's practically inspiring even if philosophically shallow. They analyze the value of concrete stories, the lack of systematic philosophy in the book, and misconceptions about the concept of will in stoicism. They also explore the meaning behind the book's title and encourage listeners to embrace obstacles as opportunities.
Ryan Holiday's book The Obstacle Is the Way switches the order of the three disciplines of stoicism, starting with perception, then action, and finally will.
The book does not strongly emphasize the cognitive theory of emotions, overlooking a key aspect of stoic philosophy and hindering readers in understanding and managing their emotions.
The book introduces the concept of the will without providing a clear understanding, obscuring the stoic understanding of desire and reason and leading to misconceptions.
Deep dives
The Book's Structure and Order of Disciplines
Ryan Holiday switches the order of the three disciplines of stoicism, starting with perception, then action, and finally will. This differs from the traditional stoic order of desire, action, and ascent.
Lack of Emphasis on Cognitive Theory of Emotions
The book does not strongly emphasize the cognitive theory of emotions, which states that our emotions are the result of our value judgments. This overlooks a key aspect of stoic philosophy and may hinder readers in understanding and managing their emotions.
Confusion around the Concept of the Will
The author introduces the concept of the will, but does not provide a clear understanding of what he means by it. This confusion obscures the stoic understanding of desire and reason, and may lead to misconceptions and misunderstandings.
Lack of Religious or Spiritual Elements
The book tends to overlook and diminish the religious and spiritual aspects of stoicism, focusing more on practical strategies and motivational anecdotes. This neglects important components of stoic philosophy, such as the concept of fate and deeper purpose.
Lack of a Systematic Philosophy
The book reads more like a series of blog posts rather than a cohesive and logically structured exploration of stoicism. It does not dig deep into the theoretical foundations of stoic philosophy, which are necessary for a thorough understanding and practice of stoicism.
In this conversation, Michael and Caleb discuss Ryan Holiday’s book The Obstacle Is the Way. They cover the good, bad, and provocative.
Both argue that it’s practically inspiring even if philosophically shallow. Michael argues that in a real sense, it’s not a Stoic book. Caleb pushes back – a little.
(05:30) Protreptic Philosophy
(11:44) The Necessity of Popularization
(14:35) Stoicism as An Operating System
(19:00) Motivational Power
(22:01) Shallow Stoicism
(31:16) Holiday Didn't Understand Stoicism
(33:32) Muddling Through Stoic Theory
(41:38) The Cognitive Theory of Emotions
(47:03) The Spiritual Aspect of Stoicism
(48:54) 3 Disciplines
(53:43) Meditations 5 20
***
Subscribe to The Stoa Letter for weekly meditations, actions, and links to the best Stoic resources: www.stoaletter.com/subscribe