Adam Phillips, a leading Freud expert, chats with Lisa Appignanesi, former Chair of the Freud Museum. They dive deep into writing Freud’s biography, tackling the challenges of capturing his complex identity and personal history. The discussion explores childhood trauma, Freud's transformative Parisian experiences, and the evolving dynamics of gender in early psychoanalysis. They also touch on the interplay between literature and psychoanalysis, revealing how works like Shakespeare's influenced Freud’s theories and practices.
Adam Phillips emphasizes the creative challenges of writing Freud's biography, highlighting the tension between factual accuracy and artistic expression.
The exploration of Freud's Jewish heritage and immigration journey underscores the influence of cultural identity on his psychoanalytic theories.
Phillips discusses the interplay between biography and psychoanalysis, advocating for understanding subjectivity without claiming absolute biographical truths.
Deep dives
Introduction to the Autumn Series and Key Figures
The podcast begins with an introduction to an event launched by the Freud Museum as part of their Autumn Series, which is set away from the museum itself and connects to Freud's legacy. Danny Nobis, the chair of the museum, highlights the prominence of Adam Phillips, a well-known psychoanalyst and cultural figure, and author of the latest volume titled 'Becoming Freud.' Nobis also introduces Lisa Appignanesi, a noted novelist and cultural commentator, who will engage Phillips in conversation about his work, setting the scene for an intellectually stimulating discussion that bridges psychoanalysis and broader cultural themes.
Challenges of Biographical Writing
Adam Phillips discusses the complexities of writing a biography, particularly a biography focused on Freud, who expressed reservations about the genre itself. He reflects on the inherent limitations biographies impose due to their reliance on established facts and narratives. Phillips conveys his initial misgivings about the project, emphasizing his preference for a more fluid and imaginative writing style that allows for creative exploration rather than strict adherence to chronology or factual accuracy. This perspective illustrates the tension between capturing a life accurately and the artistic freedom he values in writing.
Freud’s Jewish Identity and Background
Phillips expresses interest in examining Freud's Jewish heritage and its influence on his life and work, particularly during a time of significant cultural shifts in Central Europe. He shares how undertaking this biography is also about exploring broader themes of immigration and identity, especially in the context of Freud's own migration journey from Moravia to Vienna. The exploration reveals the profound impact that cultural and familial roots have on shaping an individual's psychological landscape, and how these aspects intertwine with the development of psychoanalysis as a discipline. This thematic exploration aims to highlight how identity plays a crucial role in the formation of both personal and professional trajectories.
Freud's Relationship with the Concept of Biography
The conversation delves into Freud's skepticism toward biographical truth, with Phillips illustrating Freud’s concern about the inherent inaccuracies that come with biographical accounts. Freud's belief that biographies are often filled with exaggerations and subjective interpretations raises questions about the legitimacy of biographical writing as a form of truth-telling. Phillips suggests that despite Freud's criticisms, there is value in understanding psychoanalysis through a biographical lens, as it can provide insights into the complexities of a subject's life without claiming absolute truth. This interplay between biography and psychoanalysis underlines the notion that both fields require careful navigation of subjectivity and interpretation.
Psychoanalysis as a Reflection of Immigration Experiences
Phillips articulates the notion that psychoanalysis resonates deeply with themes of immigration and the challenges of personal identity that come with it. By likening Freud’s experiences as an immigrant in Vienna to the struggles faced by many individuals navigating identity, Phillips positions psychoanalysis as a means of understanding the feelings of dislocation and ambiguity produced by cultural assimilation. He draws parallels between the experiences of children in psychoanalysis and the immigrant experience, emphasizing the psychoanalytic focus on the nuances of identity formation and the often painful process of finding one’s place in an unfamiliar context. This comparison enriches the understanding of psychoanalysis as a field that speaks not just to individual psychology but also to broader cultural dynamics.
Adam Phillips in conversation with Lisa Appignanesi Adam Phillips, one of the world’s foremost authorities on Freud discusses his strikingly original new biography of the father of psychoanalysis, Becoming Freud: The Making of a Psychoanalyst (Yale University Press 2014), with Lisa Appignanesi, former Chair of the Freud Museum London and author most recently of Trials of Passion: Crimes in the Name of Love and Madness.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode