Rabbi Shai Held, an insightful author exploring love within Jewish life, dives deep into the complexities of faith and tradition. He challenges the notion that religion provides clear answers, suggesting instead that some questions are meant to linger. Rabbi Held discusses the vibrant nature of Jewish laws, the intertwining of duty and joy, and the profound commitment of love in Jewish practice. He emphasizes reclaiming Jewish identity, human dignity, and the importance of self-love in fostering true empathy.
Rabbi Shai Held emphasizes that love is integral to Judaism, presenting it as a dynamic force rather than mere adherence to law.
He reframes duty in Jewish life as a source of joy and fulfillment, showing that obligations can coexist with personal delight.
Held advocates for a dialogical approach to sacred texts, prioritizing the value of questions and ongoing interpretation for spiritual growth.
Deep dives
Reimagining Judaism as a Tradition of Love
Judaism is often mischaracterized as a lifeless and loveless tradition, particularly through the lens of historical anti-Judaism. Rabbi Held argues that love is essential to every aspect of the Jewish tradition, advocating for a dynamic understanding that emphasizes love rather than mere adherence to law. This reclaiming of love underscores that Jewish spirituality incorporates grace and that law is a manifestation of love, rather than its opposite. For instance, Maimonides articulates that the very existence of creation is an act of grace, intertwining Jewish thought with profound themes of love and compassion.
Duty and Delight: A Complementary Relationship
Rabbi Held discusses the duality of duty and delight in Jewish life, challenging the common perception that duty is burdensome. He suggests that fulfilling one’s obligations, such as caring for family or community, can coexist with finding joy in those same actions. This perspective reframes duty as a fundamental aspect of human identity rather than a burdensome requirement. Thus, actions that honor our duties can also bring satisfaction, suggesting that true fulfillment lies in harmonizing both aspects.
Love as Orientation: Beyond Emotion
In addressing the complex nature of love, Rabbi Held emphasizes love as an orientation rather than merely an emotion, which can be fleeting. This understanding allows individuals to maintain a commitment to love even in times of emotional turmoil, suggesting that spiritual life should be rooted in a disposition towards love and action. He emphasizes that genuine love encompasses both emotional and actionable elements, calling for a holistic integration of feelings and behaviors. This approach resists the pressure to always feel love while remaining committed to embodying it.
Engagement with Text and Tradition
Rabbi Held advocates for a dialogical approach to engaging with Jewish texts, emphasizing the importance of questions over definitive answers. He draws on the notion of co-revelation, where both divine and human insights emerge through scriptural study. This interaction invites a respectful humility towards sacred texts while encouraging an active participation in their interpretation and understanding. Such a process fosters a rich, ongoing conversation that enhances both spiritual growth and personal insight within the tradition.
Memory and Empathy: The Role of Suffering
Rabbi Held highlights the transformative power of memory in shaping our responses to suffering, urging a shift from a self-focused narrative of trauma to one that fosters empathy for others. The biblical injunction to remember the experience of oppression impels adherents to respond compassionately to the struggles of strangers. This connection between personal memory and communal responsibility underscores the spiritual obligation to advocate for those who suffer. By consciously choosing how to interpret painful experiences, individuals can cultivate a narrative that prioritizes love and care for others in the face of historical and personal struggles.
This is our unabridged interview with Rabbi Shai Held.
“I think part of what it means to live in an honest way with a religious tradition is to live with its ragged edges.”
It’s not unusual to assume that one of religion's prime functions is to give us answers. But what if some of life’s hardest questions weren’t meant to be answered, but rather perpetually asked?
In this episode, Rabbi Shai Held, author of the book, "Judaism is About Love: Recovering the Heart of Jewish Life,” exemplifies this possibility, engaging the messiness and joy of life with honest grappling. He argues that some Jews have internalized traditional anti-Jewish bias and he seeks to help recover what has been lost. He shows that love and grace are at the center of a good life.
Amazon Affiliate Disclosure: Tokens Media, LLC is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode