Jonathan Cribb, Associate Director at IFS, and Baroness Ros Altmann discuss challenges with the state pension, including the determination and value of the pension, the impact on women, moving towards universalization, and flexibility and challenges in the pension system.
Challenges surrounding the state pension system include fairness and equitable access, complexity, and concerns about its adequacy.
Raising the state pension age can lead to income disparities and inequality, particularly for vulnerable groups.
Deep dives
Overview of the State Pension
The UK is facing an aging population, with a projected increase of 25% more pensioners by 2050. The state pension is the primary means of supporting people in retirement, currently starting at age 66. The state pension has become simpler over the years, with the introduction of the new state pension. This new pension provides a flat rate of around £204 per week for those who reach pension age from 2016 onwards. The value of the state pension increases based on a rule called the triple lock, which ensures it rises in line with the highest of earnings growth, inflation, or two and a half percent. While the state pension serves as a basis for retirement income, it is not intended to be the sole income source for most pensioners.
Challenges and Considerations for the State Pension
There are challenges and complexities surrounding the state pension system. One challenge is ensuring fairness and equitable access, particularly for groups like women who may have faced lower retirement ages in the past. The state pension's eligibility criteria have been adjusted to include credits for individuals who have spent time out of work due to caregiving or disability. The state pension system is intended to provide a basic minimum income in retirement, allowing individuals to supplement their retirement income through personal savings or employer contributions. However, there are concerns regarding the adequacy of the state pension, with some calling for a higher pension relative to average earnings. There is also a need to address the complexity of the system, simplifying the calculations and eliminating gaps and loopholes that disproportionately affect certain groups.
The Impact of Increasing State Pension Age
Raising the state pension age has been a topic of debate. While an increase in the state pension age encourages people to remain in work longer, it can also leave some individuals in a vulnerable position, particularly those who are unwell or unable to work. Increasing the state pension age can lead to income disparities and inequality, as it may disadvantage those who are unable to work but haven't reached state pension age. The impact is greater for individuals with lower life expectancies, which tends to be correlated with lower socioeconomic status. It is essential to consider the social implications and ensure support structures are in place for those affected by the increase in state pension age.
Proposed Reforms and Guarantees for the State Pension
To address the challenges and ensure the sustainability of the state pension system, various reforms and guarantees have been proposed. One suggested reform is implementing a target for the state pension as a percentage of average earnings and establishing a legislative path towards achieving that target. This would provide clarity and stability for future pensioners. Additionally, it is suggested that state pension increases should be at least in line with prices, preventing a decline in real value. Means testing the state pension for higher-income individuals is not recommended, as it may discourage personal saving and undermine the success of private pension schemes. Lastly, improving communication and providing sufficient warning for changes in state pension age is crucial to give people certainty about their retirement plans.
With an ageing population, the UK faces a series of significant challenges with regard to its state pension. The OBR estimates that spending on the state pension, pension credit and winter fuel payment is expected to rise by 1.2% of national income (£32 billion per year in today’s terms) by 2050.
How does the state pension work? What are the problems with it? And how can we reform it to work more effectively?
In our final episode of the year, Paul is joined by Jonathan Cribb, Associate Director at IFS and Head of the Retirement, Savings, and Ageing sector, and Baroness Ros Altmann, a life peer, pensions expert and former Pensions Minister.
Find out more: https://ifs.org.uk/
Become a member: https://ifs.org.uk/individual-membership
