Carey Nieuwhof, a renowned author and podcaster focused on leadership and church growth, joins to discuss leadership challenges in revitalizing struggling congregations. They explore the balance of honoring past leaders while fostering a new culture after moral failures. Nieuwhof shares insights on the importance of patience, vulnerability, and effective communication in rebuilding trust. The conversation emphasizes transforming organizational culture and navigating the complexities of leading inherited organizations, along with the healing journeys of both leaders and communities.
Leaders stepping into broken churches must prioritize rebuilding trust through transparency and open communication to foster a supportive environment.
Navigating leadership transitions after moral failures requires patience and discernment to earn credibility amidst a skeptical community.
Establishing a strong support network of mentors and fellow leaders is crucial for overcoming the unique challenges associated with re-leading organizations.
Deep dives
The Role of a Re-Leader
Many leaders find themselves in positions where they inherit challenges rather than create something from scratch. This experience often leads to the realization that their true calling may involve fixing what others have broken. The speaker reflects on their journey through various leadership roles, where they consistently took over struggling organizations, ranging from a sales territory to a church community. This repetitive theme highlights a unique trait of certain leaders—an ability and calling to revitalize and restore rather than just build anew.
Challenges of Church Leadership Transitions
Leadership transitions in churches, especially following moral failures, present daunting challenges. Statistics indicate that in the U.S., many churches close each year, emphasizing the importance of skilled re-leaders who can rejuvenate failing institutions. The speaker recounts their experience stepping into a church after a scandal, noting the difficult environment with staff and congregants uncertain about their new leader. The importance of patience and discernment is underscored as they navigate this unique dynamic, emphasizing that leaders need time to earn trust and establish credibility.
Building Trust and Culture
Establishing trust is crucial when stepping into any leadership role, especially in a recovery context. The speaker advocates for transparency in communication, sharing vital information about the organization's performance and challenges to garner trust and connection. Their practice of conducting annual 'state of the church' addresses promotes openness, allowing congregants to understand the inner workings of the church better. Over time, this openness can influence the organizational culture, leading to healthier dynamics and stronger commitments from the community.
Navigating Leadership Mistakes
Leaders often learn the hard way about the pitfalls of chasing down every departing person in an attempt to maintain attendance and support. The speaker reflects on their early inclination toward people-pleasing, spurred by fear during turbulent times, which ultimately led to mistakes. They emphasize the necessity of recognizing when it’s time to let go, allowing individuals to leave without attempting to retrieve every single person. The use of analogies, such as equating leadership with nurturing a living organism, illustrates the idea that healthy leadership allows for natural growth, change, and transitions.
The Importance of Community for Leaders
A strong support community is vital for leaders, particularly those who find themselves in re-leading scenarios. Engaging with other leaders who have faced similar challenges provides invaluable insights and preparation for unforeseen obstacles. The speaker highlights the necessity of surrounding oneself with mentors who have experienced the realities of re-leadership, ensuring a network where shared experiences can facilitate growth. This community can offer both practical advice and emotional support, helping leaders navigate the complexities of revitalizing failing organizations.
Welcome back, ReLeaders! In this episode, Jon Chastain dives into the unique challenges of stepping into leadership roles where the groundwork has already been laid—but often with cracks that need mending. From navigating the complexities of inheriting a church after a moral failure to rebuilding trust and creating a new culture, Jon shares invaluable insights alongside Carey Nieuwhof. Tune in as they explore the delicate balance of honoring the past while confidently leading into the future, with practical strategies for overcoming fear-based leadership and fostering a supportive community of fellow ReLeaders.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode