Zack Czajkowski is a former political director at the Lincoln Project, and James Lynch has worked with high-profile political campaigns. They discuss Donald Trump's unique photo op at McDonald's, aiming to connect with working-class voters, and how it contrasts with Kamala Harris's strategies. The conversation shifts to the new 'podcast election' phenomenon, highlighting how platforms like podcasts influence political communication and engage younger audiences, transforming how candidates shape their public image.
Trump's McDonald's photo op is perceived as a populist strategy to connect with working-class voters yet criticized as a superficial stunt.
The contrasting campaign strategies of Trump and Harris reflect their political identities, focusing on populism versus democracy, respectively.
Podcasts are emerging as a significant medium in the election, enabling candidates to engage with diverse audiences through informal and relatable content.
Deep dives
Trump's Appeal to Working-Class Voters
Polling indicates that Donald Trump is losing traction with non-college educated white voters, a demographic critical to his previous victories. In 2016, he won this group by 33 points, which dropped to 31 points in 2020, and is reported to be down to 27 points in 2024 according to CNN. This decline is particularly significant in key swing states like Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, where Trump has lost three points over consecutive elections. As his campaign gears up to connect with working-class voters, his recent photo op at McDonald's has raised questions about the effectiveness and authenticity of his outreach strategies.
The McDonald's Stunt and its Implications
Trump's recent photo op at McDonald's, where he dressed in an apron and served fries, is viewed by some as a clever appeal to working-class voters yet criticized as merely a political stunt. Critics argue that this event distracts from pressing issues like minimum wage increases, which directly affect the financial stability of many Americans. Trump's remarks about Kamala Harris's past employment at McDonald's lack substantiation and may serve to shift focus from substantial policy conversations. Both Zach and James highlight how such antics are classic Trump, emphasizing showmanship over genuine engagement with vital topics affecting the electorate.
Contrasting Campaign Strategies of Trump and Harris
Trump and Harris are employing starkly different strategies to resonate with voters, reflecting their contrasting political identities. While Trump is cultivating an image as a pro-worker, populist figure offering tax incentives, Harris aims to position herself as a defender of democracy and an advocate against Trump's authoritarian tendencies. Observers note that Harris's messaging may struggle to penetrate through to undecided voters who are largely disengaged from traditional political narratives. This divergence illustrates the broader narrative tussle where each candidate seeks not only to affirm their policy positions but also to shape their public persona in a polarized media landscape.
The Influence of Podcasts in the 2024 Election Cycle
Podcasts are playing an increasingly important role in the 2024 election cycle, with both Trump and Harris seeking to leverage these platforms to reach broader audiences. Trump's podcast appearances with popular figures like Joe Rogan signify an attempt to connect with younger and predominantly male listeners, while Harris has opted for interviews on platforms like 'Call Her Daddy' to engage female voters. The accessibility and informal nature of podcasting allow candidates to present more relatable sides of themselves, in contrast to conventional media interviews that often lack depth. This shift suggests that both candidates recognize the importance of diversifying their outreach methods in an evolving media landscape.
The Risks of Political Messaging in Today's Media Landscape
The current media landscape presents unique challenges for candidates trying to convey authentic messages to voters amidst an environment rife with disinformation. Both Trump and Harris are navigating this complexity as they attempt to communicate their core values and lift their campaign narratives above sensationalism. The discussion indicates a growing frustration with mainstream media's focus on trivialities rather than substantial policy debates, which dilutes the public's understanding of crucial issues. Experts emphasize that effective communication means connecting emotionally with voters and fostering dialogue through trusted channels, which podcasts increasingly represent.
To unlock Politicology+ visit politicology.com/plus
This week, we dive into Donald Trump’s trip to McDonalds and how both campaigns are trying to position themselves with working class voters.
Then, we’ll look at Trump plans to sit down with Joe Rogan and Harris joining Brené Brown, and what the “podcast election” is revealing about the changing media landscape.
Finally, we head to Politicology+ where we discuss Trump’s longest-serving Chief of Staff, John Kelly, speaking out and warning that Trump would rule like a dictator.
Joining guest host Hagar Chemali on this week’s panel:
Zack Czajkowski (Fmr. Lincoln Project Political Director)
James Lynch (Communications Strategist)
Segments this week:
(04:29) The McDonald’s Photo Op
(25:26) The Podcast Election
Not yet a Politicology+ member? Don’t miss all the extra episodes on the private, ad-free version of this podcast. Upgrade now at politicology.com/plus.
Send your questions and thoughts to podcast@politicology.com or leave a voicemail at (202) 455-4558
