SGEM#458: Hurt So Good –Ketamine Can Make the Hurt so Good – If used as an Adjunct to Opioids for Acute Pain in the Emergency Department
Nov 2, 2024
auto_awesome
Dr. Neil Dasgupta, an emergency medicine physician and program director, and Dr. Steen Galili, an anesthesiology specialty trainee, dive into the innovative use of low-dose ketamine to enhance opioid efficacy for acute pain management. They discuss a compelling case study of a cyclist in distress and the challenges of treating pain in patients with chronic opioid use. The duo highlights the need for refined pain management strategies, the ethical complexities of patient recruitment for research, and the promise that ketamine holds in revolutionizing acute pain treatment.
Ketamine, as an adjunct to opioids, significantly improves pain relief in acute scenarios, reducing overall opioid requirements in emergency settings.
Research highlights challenges in recruiting chronic opioid users for studies, underscoring the complexities of pain management in emergency medicine.
Deep dives
The Challenge of Acute Pain Management
Effective management of acute pain poses significant challenges in emergency departments, particularly with patients who have chronic pain or are regular opioid users. Many patients seek relief in the emergency room due to their pain, and providers must find ways to alleviate this pain quickly and effectively. Traditional alternatives, like NSAIDs, often have limitations due to their analgesic ceiling and potential side effects, highlighting the need for better strategies. As the medical community becomes more aware of the consequences of opioid overprescription, a careful approach to pain relief is imperative, leading to the exploration of alternative treatments.
Ketamine as a Multimodal Pain Management Tool
Ketamine, a non-competitive NMDA receptor antagonist, is gaining attention for its potential in acute pain management, particularly as an adjunct to opioids. It offers effective analgesia and sedation while minimizing respiratory depression, making it a unique option in situations where traditional opioids fall short. Recent research supports the use of low-dose ketamine to improve pain outcomes when paired with morphine, allowing for more effective pain relief while reducing opioid requirements. This combination could lead to more favorable patient experiences and reduce the risks associated with high-dose opioid therapy.
Research Insights on Ketamine's Efficacy
A recent randomized controlled trial examined the effectiveness of low-dose ketamine as an adjunct to morphine for treating acute pain in emergency department patients. The results indicated ketamine significantly improved pain reduction in both opioid-tolerant and non-opioid-tolerant patients compared to morphine alone. Primary outcomes revealed a more substantial pain score decrease at 10 minutes after administration, suggesting that ketamine can provide quicker relief in acute pain situations. However, researchers noted limitations in sample size and demographic disparities, raising questions about the broader applicability of the findings across diverse populations.
Challenges in Patient Recruitment and Study Limitations
Recruiting eligible patients for the ketamine study faced several challenges, including the limited number of chronic opioid users who sought treatment in emergency settings. Research methods indicated that many potential participants either had their pain managed elsewhere or declined to participate due to existing pain management strategies. Moreover, concerns were raised regarding selection bias, as the patient demographics between the treatment and placebo groups exhibited notable differences. These limitations highlight the complexity of conducting clinical research in emergency medicine and the necessity of adapting methodologies to the unique needs of this patient population.
Date: October 29, 2024
Reference: Galili et al. Low dose ketamine as an adjunct to morphine: a randomized controlled trial among patients with and without current opioid use. AEM Oct 2024.
Guest Skeptic: Dr. Neil Dasgupta is an emergency medicine physician and ED intensivist from Long Island, NY. He is the Vice Chair of the Emergency Department and Program Director of the EM residency program at Nassau University Medical Center in East Meadow, NY, the safety net hospital for Nassau County.
Case: You are hitting the zone in your shift, a veritable disposition machine meeting the constant flow of patients through the emergency department (ED). As you finish a note on a complex critically ill patient, you hear howls of pain coming from the EMS triage desk. A 38-year-old male patient in cycling gear is being brought in after colliding with a lamp post with an obvious upper extremity deformity. He explains loudly to the triage nurse that he has chronic back pain from multiple prior cycling accidents, and regularly takes significant doses of extended-release oxycodone. As you walk over to assess the patient, you take note of how distressed he is and consider how to get him comfortable enough to work him up in the ED.
Background: Management of acute pain is an important activity of emergency physicians and can be challenging. Patients frequently come to the ED because they are in pain, and our ability to relieve that pain is central to the patient experience. Alternatives to opiate pain medications have significant limitations with analgesic ceilings (NSAIDs) as well as side effects or toxicity potential that limit their use and efficacy. This issue is even more fraught with difficulty in a patient who chronically uses opioid medications and has developed a tolerance.
Within the House of Medicine, there has been a significant shift in the use of opioids as we are more fully understanding the patient consequences and societal effects of a previously more liberal pain management strategy. Judicious use of medications became paramount, with physicians becoming wary of the over-aggressive treatment of acute pain, leaving many patients hurting and frustrated. One effective strategy is a multi-modal approach to pain management, including using adjuvant non-opioid medications for better pain control while attempting to minimize the dose of opiates.
Enter ketamine. Ketamine is a non-competitive N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist that was most used as a dissociative anesthetic. It provides excellent sedation, analgesia and amnesia while having a favourable hemodynamic profile and preserving airway reflexes. It has become a favourite medication in emergency departments for procedural sedation as well as a useful behavioural takedown medication. More recently, sub-dissociative doses of ketamine have been used to treat acute pain.
We have covered the use of ketamine multiple times on the SGEM, and there will be a list of those episodes at the end of this podcast. The most recent episode was SGEM#457 looking at nebulized ketamine.
Clinical Question: Is ketamine an effective adjunct agent along with morphine for acute pain control in the ED?
Reference: Galili et al. Low dose ketamine as an adjunct to morphine: a randomized controlled trial among patients with and without current opioid use. AEM Oct 2024.
Population: Patients over 18 years old in a single center in Denmark presenting to the ED with acute pain rated ≥5 on a numeric rating scale (NRS) from 0–10 that the ED physician decided required intravenous opioids.
Intervention: Administration of low-dose ketamine (LDK) 0.1 mg/kg intravenous (IV) bolus in addition to morphine IV dosed by clinical practice guidelines and adjusted if the patient is currently on opioid medication.
Comparison: Administration of isotonic saline as placebo with morphine
Outcome:
Primary Outcome: Pain reduction as measured by patient-reported pain...
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode