The Economics of Tariffs and Trade (with Doug Irwin)
May 5, 2025
auto_awesome
This conversation features Doug Irwin, an economist from Dartmouth College who specializes in trade policy. He tackles whether the U.S. is a victim of trade and unpacks the complexities of trade deficits. Irwin also clarifies misconceptions about tariffs and their impact on manufacturing jobs. Additionally, he discusses the evolution of manufacturing amidst globalization and technological changes, urging innovative solutions for affected workers. The episode emphasizes the intricacies of trade dynamics and cautions against simplistic views on protectionism.
Trade deficits can signify a strong economy capable of consuming more than it produces, rather than an outright economic failure.
The dynamic nature of trade shifts jobs across sectors, indicating that trade can lead to job transitions without necessarily harming overall employment.
While tariffs may seem beneficial for protecting domestic industries, they can raise consumer prices and ultimately hurt competitiveness and economic health.
Deep dives
Understanding Trade Deficits
A trade deficit occurs when a country imports more goods and services than it exports, resulting in a negative balance of trade. This situation often leads to concerns about economic health and dependency on foreign countries. However, rather than being an outright negative, a trade deficit can indicate that a country's economy is strong enough to consume more than it produces. In the United States, this phenomenon includes running a trade deficit with the world and various individual countries, highlighting the complexities of international trade and economic relationships.
The Flow of Dollars
When the United States imports more than it exports, it sends dollars abroad to pay for these goods. Interestingly, many of these dollars return to the U.S. as foreign investors purchase American assets. This creates a balance where, while the U.S. may run trade deficits, it is also a net receiver of investment, indicating robust economic conditions. It suggests that the U.S. capital account surplus is a crucial aspect of the overall economic picture, softening the impact of trade deficits.
Implications of Trade Deficits
The existence of a trade deficit does not inherently indicate a problem for the economy, especially for the U.S., as it benefits from the dollar being the world’s reserve currency. Historical perspectives, such as those from Adam Smith, argue that concerns surrounding trade deficits are often overstated or misplaced. Many economists suggest that trade deficits should not be a primary concern, as they do not directly affect immediate economic conditions for everyday people. Rather, they emphasize that the overall economic health of a nation should be the primary focus.
Changes in Employment and Trade
The relationship between trade deficits and employment is complex, as trade dynamics can shift jobs rather than eliminate them. While some industries may suffer due to foreign competition, overall job numbers can remain stable or even improve, given a dynamic economy. Trade can lead to job transitions, with some workers moving into more prosperous sectors or new roles that emerge due to economic shifts. This reality underscores that trade doesn't necessarily harm employment in totality but can change the nature of jobs available.
The Role of Tariffs
The discussion on tariffs centers on whether imposing them can help reduce trade deficits or stimulate domestic industries. Evidence suggests that tariffs often lead to higher consumer prices, as importers typically pass these costs on to customers. Moreover, while intended to protect domestic jobs, they can also hamper competitiveness and increase costs for downstream industries reliant on imports. The challenge lies in balancing the protection of domestic industries while avoiding negative consequences for the economy as a whole.
Historical Context of Trade Policies
Historically, significant changes in trade policy have often been met with public resistance and considerable economic impacts. Examples from the past indicate that tariff increases, like the Smoot-Hawley Tariff during the Great Depression, resulted in widespread economic downturns. In the current environment, despite low unemployment and stable economic conditions, public opinion appears to be shifting towards a protectionist stance. Assessing the long-term ramifications of these trends is essential, as history shows that protectionist measures can have unintended consequences for overall economic well-being.
Is the United States victimized by trade? What causes trade deficits? Are higher tariffs a good idea? Can manufacturing jobs return to the United States? Economist Doug Irwin of Dartmouth College answers these questions and more in this wide-ranging conversation with EconTalk's Russ Roberts.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
