How Environment Shapes Moral Progress (Meditation 3.9)

7 snips

Mar 4, 2025

Explore the vital role of rational judgment in shaping moral character, influenced heavily by our surroundings. Discover how Stoicism warns against early indoctrination and emphasizes a supportive environment for ethical growth. Delve into parenting challenges, focusing on leading by example rather than imposing beliefs. Gain insights on fostering moral progress even in unsupportive settings, highlighting the power of mentorship and community in navigating ethical dilemmas. Embrace the journey toward Virtue with practical steps and open-mindedness.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Rationality's Role

Stoicism views rationality as the key to virtue and living in accordance with nature.
Our upbringing and environment heavily influence our moral development.

INSIGHT

Environmental Influence

Early exposure to philosophy can be a form of indoctrination, hindering genuine moral growth.
We internalize the beliefs and values of our surroundings, shaping our character.

ADVICE

Delayed Introduction

Avoid introducing Stoicism or other complex philosophies to young people too early.
Early indoctrination can prevent them from choosing their own paths.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

This episode explores Meditations 3.9, where Marcus Aurelius urges us to revere our rational faculty. In Stoicism, rationality is our greatest gift—it’s the tool that allows us to pursue Virtue, shape our moral character, and ultimately live in accordance with Nature. But how do we cultivate this faculty, especially when our environment doesn’t support moral growth?

I discuss how we are shaped by our surroundings, often without realizing it. If we’re immersed in Stoic teachings, the path to moral improvement becomes clearer. If we’re surrounded by different influences—religious, ideological, or otherwise—we internalize those instead. This is why the Stoics believed that introducing philosophy too early could be a form of indoctrination rather than genuine moral development.

As a new father, I reflect on the challenge of raising a child without forcing beliefs upon them. The goal isn’t to dictate what’s right but to create an environment where they can discover Virtue for themselves. The same applies to guiding friends and family—lead by example rather than preaching. For those struggling to commit to moral improvement in a non-Stoic environment, I offer three actionable steps: recognize the need for guidance, seek a mentor, and eventually mentor others when ready.

Marcus Aurelius reminds us that our rational judgment must align with Nature. By shaping our habits and seeking wisdom, we give ourselves the best chance at living a life of Virtue.

“Reverence your faculty of judgement. On this it entirely rests that your governing self no longer has a judgement disobedient to Nature and to the estate of a reasonable being. This judgement promises deliberateness, familiar friendship with our fellow human beings, and to follow in the train of the gods.” — Meditations 3.9

Join The Society of Stoics, my private community for those committed to Stoic practice. For $10/month, you’ll get ad-free episodes, live discussions, weekly journaling prompts, and more. Sign up at https://community.stoicismpod.com.