The Great Political Films: Mr Smith Goes to Washington
Oct 17, 2024
auto_awesome
Dive into the charming yet complex world of a classic political film that explores the battle between the idealistic underdog and a corrupt establishment. Discover how the character of Jefferson Smith mirrors historical figures, shedding light on themes of political innocence versus cynicism. The discussion extends into the intricacies of the filibuster and the influence of public opinion, revealing the duality of democracy. It’s a thought-provoking examination of integrity, corruption, and the evolution of American politics.
The film 'Mr. Smith Goes to Washington' portrays the struggle of an innocent individual against a corrupt political establishment, highlighting the classic hero's journey amid cynicism.
The narrative critiques the political system's manipulation of public perception, revealing how corruption permeates not just actions but also the very fabric of democracy.
Through the character of Senator Payne, the film explores the conflict between ambition and conscience, questioning the possibility of effecting change within a flawed system.
Deep dives
The Heartwarming Yet Sinister Narrative
The film 'Mr. Smith Goes to Washington' is presented as a quintessential American political tale that combines feel-good sentiments with underlying cynicism. It follows Jefferson Smith, an innocent character who rises against the corrupt political machinery in Washington, resonating with the classic hero's journey popularized in sports films. The narrative effectively engages the audience's emotions, making them root for the underdog while also unveiling the dark side of politics that often lurks beneath the surface of seemingly innocent stories. The film's ability to balance warmth and cynicism contributes to its reputation as a complex, grown-up exploration of American democracy.
Corruption in American Politics
The storyline revolves around the political appointment of Jefferson Smith as a senator following the death of a previous senator, highlighting the corrupt nature of the selection process influenced by machines and bosses. Governor's dilemma in choosing a candidate reveals his discomfort with the corrupt political landscape, suggesting that the innocence of Smith serves as a strategic façade for preserving machine politics. The film implies that corruption isn't just in actions but also in the manipulation of public perception, as the machine wields power to control both the political narrative and the fate of individuals. This reflects a broader critique of how political systems can be shaped by interests that overshadow genuine democratic values.
The Role of the Senate
The film positions the U.S. Senate as a prestigious institution, yet one that is riddled with corruption and inefficiency, represented through Smith's entry as a novice politician. As he arrives in Washington, his naivete becomes a tool against a complex political system that values national dignity over transparency and accountability. The Senate’s rules and procedures, particularly the filibuster, serve as both a weapon and a shield, illustrating how they can be manipulated to empower or suppress voices within the chamber. Jefferson's struggle to navigate this rigid institution effectively underscores a critique of how political mechanisms can obscure the truth while allowing manipulation to persist.
The Importance of the Filibuster
As a key element in the film, the filibuster represents not only Smith's fight against corruption but also illustrates the inherent duality of legislative procedures. While the filibuster allows him to voice his objections and draw public attention to the corrupt practices, it also symbolizes a bureaucratic device that can be used to stall meaningful progress. The climactic scenes of Smith's persistence highlight how genuine efforts are often challenged by the very systems designed to uphold democracy, suggesting that those willing to speak up face tremendous opposition. The film presents this struggle as a crucial examination of how political processes can be harnessed for both good and ill.
The Nuanced Portrayal of Politicians
The characters in the film represent a spectrum of political integrity, particularly seen through the lens of Senator Joseph Payne, who embodies the conflict between ambition and conscience. Payne's internal struggle and ultimate compromise illuminate the difficulties faced by those within a corrupt system, making the film's political commentary even more poignant. While Jefferson is the embodiment of innocence and integrity, Payne's character introduces complexity that begs the question of whether one can effect change from inside an imperfect system. This dynamic between the characters encourages viewers to reflect on the nature of political ethics and the potential for redemption amidst systemic corruption.
Today’s great political film is Frank Capra’s Mr Smith Goes to Washington (1939), a much-loved tale of the little guy taking on the corrupt establishment. But there’s far more to it than that, including an origin story that suggests Jefferson Smith (James Stewart) might not be what he seems. From filibusters to fascism, from the New Deal to America First, from Burton K. Wheeler to Harry S. Truman, this is a heart-warming film that still manages to go to the dark heart of American politics.
To hear our bonus episode on Philip Roth’s The Plot Against America (in which Burton K. Wheeler becomes America’s Hitler) sign up now to PPF+ for just £5 per month or £50 a year and get all our other bonuses plus ad free listening https://www.ppfideas.com/join-ppf-plus