Return to Monkey Island with Ron Gilbert and Dave Grossman
Oct 31, 2022
auto_awesome
Ron Gilbert and Dave Grossman, creators of the Monkey Island series, discuss their journey into game development, developing the series at LucasArts, balancing the old and new in Return to Monkey Island, and tackling controversial endings.
The Return to Monkey Island game aimed to strike a balance between honoring the past and offering a novel experience.
The puzzle design in the game focused on being challenging and engaging while respecting the player's time.
The game's narrative choices and character relationships were carefully crafted to feel authentic and add depth to the overall experience.
Innovative features and optional collectibles were introduced to enhance gameplay and provide engaging elements beyond nostalgia.
The design process for difficulty levels and puzzle solutions involved creating a hard mode first and then removing puzzles for the easy mode.
The game's artistic style avoided being purely pixel art to feel fresh, yet still capture the essence of the Monkey Island series.
Deep dives
The Origins of the Return to Monkey Island
The idea to create a new Monkey Island game started with a casual conversation between Austin Winter and Nigel Lori. Austin Winter was approached by Nigel Lori, who had connections in Disney licensing, and they discussed the possibility of obtaining the license for Monkey Island. Winter then reached out to Dave Grossman, and together they brainstormed ideas for a new Monkey Island game. One key decision they made was to start the game right after Monkey Island 2, addressing and reimagining the controversial ending of the second game. This decision set the stage for a new, yet familiar, adventure.
Balancing Nostalgia and Innovation
The team behind the Return to Monkey Island wanted to create a game that respected the original series while also offering something new and fresh. They made a conscious effort to avoid relying too heavily on nostalgia, ensuring that the game was not simply a rehash of familiar elements. They wanted to make sure that the game appealed to both long-time fans and new players, striking a balance between honoring the past and offering a novel experience. This approach resulted in a game that captured the essence of Monkey Island while still feeling contemporary and engaging.
Evolution of Puzzle Design
The puzzle design in the Return to Monkey Island reflects the team's evolution and their desire to respect the player's time. They aimed to create puzzles that were challenging and engaging, while avoiding frustrating or overly complex solutions. The team wanted the game to feel smooth and enjoyable, ensuring that the puzzles flowed seamlessly with the story and never felt like arbitrary obstacles. Their experience and desire to respect the modern player's time guided their approach in designing puzzles that were entertaining but not overly time-consuming.
Character Relationships and Narrative Choices
The Return to Monkey Island takes a thoughtful approach to character relationships and narrative choices. The game explores the relationship between Guybrush and Elaine, opting for a stronger, more supportive dynamic rather than introducing unnecessary conflict. The team aimed to capture the warmth and charm of the original games while giving the characters room to grow and evolve. By respecting the players and the characters, the narrative choices and character relationships in the game feel authentic and add depth and emotional resonance to the overall experience.
Innovative Features and Optional Collectibles
The Return to Monkey Island introduces innovative features and optional collectibles to enhance the gameplay experience. The team wanted to go beyond simple nostalgia and offer engaging elements to the players. The trivia cards feature serves as a collectible that requires players to answer questions about the game, encouraging them to be observant and engaged. This adds an extra layer of activity and enjoyment for players, making the collectibles more meaningful and rewarding. These features demonstrate the team's commitment to creating a game that respects the players' time while providing fun and interactive elements.
Designing Difficulty Levels and Puzzle Solutions
The podcast discusses the design process of creating difficulty levels and puzzle solutions for a game. The speaker mentions that the game includes an easy and hard mode, which was inspired by the game Monkey Island 2. The developers designed the hard mode first and then removed puzzles to create the easy mode. This approach ensured that playing the easy mode did not spoil the puzzles in the hard mode.
Including a Writer's Cut Option
The podcast explores the inclusion of a writer's cut option in the game. The speaker explains that this option was born out of the desire to keep certain scenes and dialogue in the game for their comedic or character-revealing value, even though they were not essential for the main narrative or puzzles. The writer's cut option allows players to experience these extra scenes and character moments, bringing more flavor to the game without affecting the core gameplay.
The Artistic Style and Ending Choices
The podcast delves into the decision-making process behind the artistic style and the ending of the game. The speaker mentions that they chose not to create a purely pixel art style to avoid it being seen as a mere nostalgia trip. Instead, they wanted the game to feel fresh and new, while still capturing the essence of the Monkey Island series. The ending of the game was intended to be a departure from traditional expectations, pulling the carpet from under the player's feet. The speaker references their love for endings that leave a lasting impact and spark discussions among players, such as the film Mulholland Drive. Overall, the ending aimed to reveal the true secret of Monkey Island and provoke deeper reflection.
The Personal Touch of the Developers
The podcast highlights some personal experiences and interactions related to the game's development. The speaker mentions how Neil Druckmann, a fan of the Monkey Island series, approached them to have a small role in the game, showcasing the impact the series had on people. Additionally, the inclusion of a time capsule letter in the game's scrap bunk was inspired by an actual letter written by the developers early on in the development process. This letter encapsulated their thoughts and aspirations for the game, ultimately leading to its inclusion in the final product.
The Emotional Impact of the Ending
The podcast explores the emotional impact of the game's ending on players. The speaker acknowledges that the ending deviated from traditional expectations, opting for a more introspective and philosophical approach. They wanted the ending to provoke thought and reflection, rather than simply delivering a predictable conclusion. The speaker references the decision to have the player turn off the lights as a poignant moment, emphasizing that it was intended to be a symbolic act of closure and introspection. The ending aimed to resonate with players on a deeper level, leaving a lasting impression.
The Balance Between Old and New
The podcast discusses the creative choices made to balance nostalgia with innovation in the game. The speaker mentions the artist Rex Crowle, who played a key role in finding a unique art style that paid homage to the original Monkey Island games while also feeling fresh. The intention was not to create a pixel art throwback, but rather to create an art style that captured the essence of the series while standing on its own. The speaker emphasizes the importance of embracing new ideas and letting the art style become its own voice in the overall experience.
The Letter to the Player
The podcast explores the inclusion of an emotional letter to the player in the game's ending. The speaker reveals that the letter was initially written as a personal time capsule by the developers, containing their thoughts and aspirations for the game. They decided to include it in the game after recognizing its resonance with the intended emotional impact of the ending. The letter serves as a parting message from the developers, expressing their gratitude and reflecting on the journey of creating the game. It adds an additional layer of depth and personal connection between the developers and the players.
Austin Wintory chats with 2 of the creators behind the Monkey Island series, Ron Gilbert and Dave Grossman on their return to the series. In addition, together they explore their journey into game development; developing the Monkey Island series at LucasArts; the creative choices they made throughout the series; balancing the old and new in Return to Monkey Island; and tackling controversial endings. Listen to this full episode now or watch this episode on our Youtube channel.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
