Asking what students need and when with Professor Anna Mills
Oct 21, 2024
auto_awesome
Professor Anna Mills, a community college writing teacher and advocate for critical AI literacy, delves into the challenges and opportunities of integrating AI into education. She discusses the importance of fostering intrinsic motivation in students while navigating AI's role in writing assignments. Mills emphasizes the need for clear boundaries and collaboration between K-12 and higher education. Additionally, she highlights innovative methods to maintain writing integrity and enhance student privacy in the age of AI.
Balancing AI integration in education is essential to foster students' creativity while enhancing their writing skills through constructive feedback.
Improved collaboration between K-12 and higher education is vital for teaching AI literacy effectively and reducing misconceptions about its use.
Deep dives
Navigating AI Literacy in Education
The integration of AI tools in education raises important questions about maintaining a balance between leveraging technology and nurturing students' individual thought processes. Educators are grappling with how much AI should be allowed in assignments while preserving a safe space for creativity and personal expression. Some instructors advocate using AI for feedback after students have drafted their work to develop their writing skills, whereas others believe that students should engage with AI throughout the writing process. Ultimately, it is crucial to establish clear boundaries surrounding AI use to ensure that students cultivate their voices and thinking skills while also benefiting from technological advancements.
Embracing Uncertainty in AI Integration
The dynamic nature of AI technology compels educators to maintain a level of uncertainty and adaptability in their teaching approaches. Rather than adhering strictly to one ideological stance, educators can benefit from engaging in open conversations about the potential advantages and shortcomings of AI in the classroom. This willingness to navigate ambiguity can foster collaboration and critical thinking among educators, inspiring them to remain receptive to new ideas and methodologies as AI continues to evolve. By embracing this uncertainty, educators can facilitate richer discussions and develop more comprehensive strategies for integrating AI in meaningful ways.
Bridging Gaps Between K-12 and Higher Education
There is a growing need for increased communication and collaboration between K-12 and higher education institutions regarding the teaching of AI literacy. Many students entering college have been taught that using AI is tantamount to cheating, which can hinder their ability to engage with new technologies constructively. Educators in higher education can learn from innovative practices in K-12 settings, where students are actively exploring AI and its applications, thus equipping them with the digital literacy skills needed in higher ed. Promoting dialogue and shared experiences between these educational levels can help create a more coherent approach to teaching AI literacy across the educational spectrum.
Encouraging Critical Engagement with AI Feedback
One approach to integrating AI tools in writing instruction involves using platforms like MyEssayFeedback, which encourages students to critically evaluate AI-generated feedback. By guiding students to reflect on the AI's suggestions and consider how those align with their own writing intentions, educators can foster a sense of ownership over their work. This process emphasizes the importance of human agency in writing while acknowledging the potential utility of AI as a supplementary tool. As students learn to navigate AI feedback constructively, they become better equipped to discern valuable insights from automated suggestions, ultimately enhancing their writing skills.
Professor Anna Mills discusses the evolving landscape of AI literacy in education, emphasizing the need for a balanced approach to integrating AI into writing and learning processes. She reflects on the challenges of defining boundaries for AI use in academic settings, the importance of fostering intrinsic motivation among students, and the necessity of bridging the gap between K-12 and higher education.
Anna Mills has taught writing at public two-year colleges in the San Francisco Bay Area for 18 years and currently teach at College of Marin. Her OER textbook, How Arguments Work: A Guide to Writing and Analyzing Texts in College, has been used at over 65 colleges. She serves as the English Discipline Lead for the California community colleges OER Initiative, and her collection AI Text Generators and Teaching Writing: Starting Points for Inquiry is featured in the Writing Across the Curriculum Clearinghouse. As a consultant for OpenAI, she tested GPT-4 before its release. Currently, she serves as volunteer advisor on the teacher-created app MyEssayFeedback.ai and as faculty for the AAC&U Institute on AI, Pedagogy, and the Curriculum. As a member of the MLA/CCCC Task Force on Writing and AI, she helped launch Exploring AI Pedagogy: A Community Collection of Teaching Reflections.