Caitlin Long on Why the Fed’s Rejections of Custodia Bank Seem Politically Motivated - Ep. 687
Aug 13, 2024
auto_awesome
Caitlin Long, an advocate for secure crypto banking and a founder of Custodia Bank, explores the controversial denial of her bank's application for a Federal Reserve master account. She discusses how Custodia met rigorous state requirements yet faced unprecedented rejection, suggesting political motivations behind the Fed’s decision. Long dives into the ongoing legal battle, the impact of Operation Choke Point 2.0, and systemic barriers in bank ownership, while criticizing regulatory biases that undermine innovation in the financial sector.
Custodia Bank was created in Wyoming to provide secure banking services for the underbanked cryptocurrency sector amid federal regulatory challenges.
The Federal Reserve's rejection of Custodia's application for a master account raised suspicions of political motivations influencing regulatory decisions against crypto firms.
Custodia's ongoing lawsuit against the Fed highlights the tension between state-chartered banks and federal oversight, revealing implications for future crypto banking regulations.
Deep dives
Book Event Announcement
The host announces a book event in Seoul, South Korea, promoting the Korean edition of her book entitled 'Ethereum Billionaires.' Scheduled for August 19th at 7 PM at a venue named Chemistry in Gangnam, the event will feature book signings and discussions among attendees interested in cryptocurrency. Participants can RSVP via a Twitter link for discounted book purchases from a local bookstore. This gathering presents an opportunity for networking among crypto enthusiasts in the region.
Custodia's Vision and Challenges
Custodia Bank was established to address the banking needs of the cryptocurrency industry, particularly in response to past de-banking incidents affecting legal businesses. The state of Wyoming aimed to create a bank charter that was recognized by the Federal Reserve but not necessarily insured by the FDIC to support crypto firms. The bank's primary goal is to offer secure banking solutions for companies unable to access traditional financial institutions due to restrictive practices. Despite pursuing this vision, Custodia has faced ongoing challenges and political pushback from federal regulatory agencies.
Regulatory Pushback on Custodia
Custodia's application for a master account with the Federal Reserve faced significant delays, attributed to internal factions opposing cryptocurrency businesses. The founders experienced a shift in the Fed's stance following political interventions, which coincided with broader governmental initiatives against digital asset firms. After lengthy discussions and assurances of progress, Custodia was ultimately denied access to the payment system, leading to legal action against the Federal Reserve for perceived unfair treatment. This situation highlights the complex regulatory landscape and the difficulties faced by innovative financial institutions.
Recent Legal Developments and Implications
A recent ruling by a district court upheld the Federal Reserve’s discretion to deny master accounts to state-chartered banks, including Custodia. This decision has raised concerns regarding the fairness of regulatory practices that may be influencing the viability of such banks amidst changing political landscapes. Custodia continues to pursue an appeal, bolstered by bipartisan support from former Solicitors General who recognize the implications of Operation Choke Point and the ramifications for the banking sector. The ongoing case underscores the challenges of navigating both regulatory approval and the evolving climate for cryptocurrency in the U.S.
The Role of State Innovation in Banking
The discussion emphasizes the importance of state-chartered banks in fostering innovation within the financial sector, contrasting with federal oversight that often stifles new ideas. CustodiaBank in Wyoming represents a novel approach to meet the needs of the cryptocurrency industry while complying with regulatory requirements. Advocates argue for a balance between federal and state regulations, highlighting states' ability to drive progress in banking practices. The conversation reflects broader themes regarding federalism and the potential for states to lead in creating regulatory frameworks accommodating emerging technologies.
Custodia, established as a special purpose depository institution in Wyoming, aimed to offer secure banking services for the crypto sector. Despite meeting state requirements and taking extra steps to demonstrate its commitment to safety, Custodia’s application for a Fed master account was met with delays and ultimately denied in an unprecedented 86-page report.
In this episode, Caitlin and Michelle explain why they believe the Fed’s rejection was politically motivated, how this relates to Operation Choke Point 2.0, the appallingly small number of American banks owned by women, where they are in their lawsuit against the Fed, and what this case means for the future of crypto banking in the U.S.
Show highlights:
00:00 Intro
01:52 What Custodia Bank is and how it got started in Wyoming
06:04 How Custodia got into a fight with the Fed to get its master account
09:58 How the dual banking system works in the U.S. and the differences between Custodia and traditional banks
18:15 Why Custodia filed a lawsuit against its own regulator
24:33 Why the Fed denied Custodia its applications and Caitlin’s response to the criticisms
29:57 The political coordination meant to “intimidate” Custodia, according to Caitlin
42:43 The amicus briefs that were filed in favor of Custodia
48:48 Caitlin’s reaction to the Fed’s enforcement action against Customers Bank
53:35 Why Caitlin says that it’s “abusive and corporatist” that the SEC is granting exceptions to big banks
56:03 Why so few banks are owned by women and whether this played a role in Custodia’s denial
59:25 The next steps in Custodia’s case and whether a stablecoin is viable for them
1:05:21 Whether the elections are going to impact the case
Visit our website for breaking news, analysis, op-eds, articles to learn about crypto, and much more: unchainedcrypto.com