Laura E. Adkins and Ari Hoffman join Yehuda Kurtzer to discuss the evolving landscape of Jewish media. They explore ideological commitments, the merging of personal and platform, balancing individual and collective identity, social networks in building communities, and cancel culture within the Jewish community.
Balancing personal associations with professional coverage is a challenge for Jewish journalists navigating deep ideological divides within the community.
The Jewish media landscape needs more independent investigative journalism to ensure accountability within Jewish institutions.
Greater funding for investigative journalism and community engagement through live events is essential for Jewish media to thrive and serve as a public square for communal discourse.
Deep dives
The Challenges of Navigating Ideological Divides in Jewish Media
Journalists in Jewish media grapple with navigating deep ideological divides within the Jewish community and representing the diversity of opinions. Balancing personal associations with professional coverage can be difficult, especially when covering topics that affect one's own life. Jewish media plays a crucial role in storytelling and narrative-making, but its independence and investigative reporting suffer due to financial constraints. There is a need for increased funding for investigative journalism and community engagement through live events. Jewish philanthropy should take bolder and riskier approaches in supporting innovative ideas and organizations, while also investing in a vibrant intellectual culture.
The Complexities of Journalistic Commitments
Journalists in Jewish media navigate multiple commitments, including serving as part of the public trust, advancing the political identity of a publication, and developing their own personal brand. Balancing these commitments can be challenging, and journalists must exercise integrity in their reporting while representing diverse perspectives within the Jewish community. The scale and dynamics of the Jewish media landscape require journalists to choose their battles wisely and tell compelling stories that matter. They must also be mindful of the potential consequences of their writing and social media presence, particularly when covering sensitive issues like anti-Semitism.
The Power and Stakes of Jewish Journalism
Jewish journalism plays a vital role in shaping narratives and advancing the public trust, but it is often viewed as a threat due to the potential consequences of dissenting views or critical reporting. The Jewish media landscape needs more independent investigative journalism to ensure accountability within Jewish institutions. Philanthropy should support riskier and more innovative projects, as well as engage in funding vibrant intellectual culture. Journalists themselves desire greater community engagement and seek to build relationships with readers through transparency, diverse perspectives, and curiosity-driven reporting that captures the essence of the Jewish experience.
Navigating the Challenges of Being a Jewish Journalist
Jewish journalists face unique challenges, particularly when covering issues that impact their own community. The nature of Jewish media requires balancing personal associations with professional coverage, which can be complicated when navigating deep ideological divides. The rise of anti-Semitism and online threats further complicates journalism within the Jewish community, necessitating careful consideration of the potential consequences of reporting. While there are risks involved, journalism remains indispensable in providing critical narratives, telling stories, and fostering community understanding during times of volatility and change.
Recommendations for Jewish Philanthropy and Readers
Philanthropy within the Jewish community should prioritize funding investigative reporting and community engagement through live events, allowing for greater institutional accountability and intellectual exploration. A bolder, riskier approach to grant-making is needed to support innovative ideas and projects. Readers are encouraged to approach the Jewish media landscape with curiosity and engage with diverse perspectives. Supporting Jewish publications and actively participating in the exchange of ideas fosters a vibrant intellectual culture and strengthens the community's ability to navigate challenges and shifts in the media landscape.
The Jewish media landscape has evolved significantly over the last few years, and has in many ways become more fragmented. In this episode, Laura E. Adkins, (Opinion Editor of the Forward) and Ari Hoffman, (Assistant Editor of the New York Sun) join Yehuda Kurtzer to discuss what happens when the mission of a publication changes and how Jewish media can continue to serve as a public square for communal discourse.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
