Deepak Shenoy, Founder of Capitalmind, and Sudhakara Reddy, Associate Professor at IIM-Calcutta, delve into SEBI's recent regulations on Futures and Options trading. They discuss the shift towards tighter restrictions aimed at protecting retail traders, highlighting the alarming rise in retail participation and significant losses incurred. The duo explores the macroeconomic implications of these changes, including liquidity concerns and the trend of funds moving to riskier bets, emphasizing the urgent need for enhanced financial literacy in this evolving landscape.
SEBI's new regulations aim to protect retail traders from significant losses in F&O trading by increasing contract sizes and limiting expiries.
The rise in retail trading participation has resulted in alarming losses, raising concerns over economic productivity and household savings.
Deep dives
Regulatory Changes in Futures and Options Trading
New regulations imposed on futures and options (F&O) trading aim to address rising concerns over retail trader losses. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has introduced significant changes, including limiting weekly expiries to one per exchange and increasing the minimum contract size to 15 lakh from 5 lakh. These adjustments raise entry barriers for small traders, making it more expensive to participate, potentially curbing reckless speculative trading. The objective of these measures is to prevent unchecked speculation, with warnings issued regarding substantial losses that could otherwise be redirected into more productive avenues for the economy.
Scale of Retail Participation and Losses
Retail participation in index options has surged dramatically, increasing from 2% in FY18 to 41% in FY24, with an alarming 91.1% of these traders incurring losses, totaling 1.81 lakh crore. This trend represents not just individual financial distress but a significant macroeconomic issue as the loss of such large sums impacts household savings and economic productivity. The zero-sum nature of F&O trading indicates that retail traders' losses effectively translate into profits for larger, algorithmic traders and foreign portfolio investors. Therefore, the surge in individual trading activity not only highlights the risks involved but also raises questions about the redistribution of wealth within the trading ecosystem.
Long-Term Implications of the New Rules
While the recent interventions by SEBI aim to mitigate risks associated with F&O trading, their long-term efficacy remains uncertain. Analysts express concerns that despite increasing the lot size and redistributing expiration days, traders may adapt by borrowing more or engaging in riskier options, thus perpetuating their likelihood of losses. Moreover, institutional participation may not expand adequately as the rules discouraging small traders inadvertently affect market liquidity. The overarching question is whether these regulations will lead to a sustainable trading environment or simply shift the existing behaviors among traders, ultimately continuing the cycle of speculation in the derivatives market.
SEBI’s new curbs on the high-stakes world of Futures and Options trading mean tighter restrictions for retail traders, such as reduced weekly expiries and increased contract sizes. The game is about to change. Host Himani Kothari talks to Deepak Shenoy, Founder of Capitalmind, and Sudhakara Reddy, Associate Professor of Finance and Control at IIM-Calcutta, to break down why Sebi has implemented these steps, the alarming rise in retail participation, and the staggering losses traders have incurred.
You can follow your debutant host Hemani Kothari on his social media: Twitter and Linkedin
ET Podcasts now has a new show. 7@7 is your quick, sharp sub 5 minute daily roundup of financial news from India and the world. Tune in to Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Prime Music, Jio Saavn, Youtube or wherever you get your podcasts from!