Homebrewed Christianity Tolkien & Trump: The Professor or the Profligate with Dr. Craig Boyd
Nov 27, 2025
Dr. Craig Boyd, an ethicist and Tolkien scholar, takes us on a fascinating journey through Tolkien's political philosophy. He highlights the stark contrast between Gandalf's humble leadership and Saruman's coercive tactics, drawing parallels to contemporary politics. Boyd critiques the alt-right's misappropriation of Tolkien, emphasizing the importance of genuine care over power. He explores themes of moral courage, the seductive nature of power, and the role of solidarity in resisting manipulation. A must-listen for fans of Tolkien and political thought alike!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Power As The Central Moral Test
- Tolkien sees the lust for power and desire to control others as the supremely bad motive in politics and story.
- Characters like Gandalf, Sam, and Faramir model resisting power while Saruman and Sauron embody domination.
Good Intentions Corrupt Power
- Tolkien shows three types of power desire: evil domination, power for 'good' ends, and resisting power.
- Even wanting power for noble aims corrupts the soul, as Gandalf and Galadriel warn.
Ruffians Break Community Bonds
- Ruffians in The Scouring of the Shire are bullies who objectify and terrorize their victims for private gain.
- Tolkien repeats 'ruffians' to highlight how power-hungry enforcers break community bonds and friendship.
