An anonymous caller shares bizarre and humorous tales, opening with a shocking dental mishap involving a murderer. Chris Gethard and the caller delve into the absurdity of life, discussing a frugal exhibitionist and chaotic retail experiences. They reflect on growing up in New Jersey, exploring nostalgia and community ties, while also navigating the thin line between fandom and cult mentality. The conversation mixes dark humor with genuine insights, culminating in a wild story of a road trip gone awry. Expect laughs and unexpected twists!
The caller's shocking encounter with a dentist who turned out to be a murderer illustrates the complexities of human personas and hidden truths.
The podcast community's support for callers sharing personal stories highlights the importance of empathy and connection among listeners facing real-life struggles.
Humorous anecdotes, like the caller's Rite Aid experience with an unexpected customer, showcase the quirky and often absurd moments found in everyday life.
Deep dives
The Unexpected Dentist Encounter
A captivating story unfolds regarding the caller's unexpected experience with a dentist who turned out to be a murderer. Initially seeking a reputable dentist in a new area, the caller chose one who appeared to have excellent ratings and a friendly demeanor. However, after some time away, they learned through an email that their dentist had been indicted for poisoning his wife with cyanide and arsenic. This shocking revelation left the caller both horrified and intrigued by the duality of the dentist's professional persona and his horrific actions.
Community Support After Heartfelt Tales
The conversation draws attention to the support the podcast community extends to callers sharing emotional stories. Previous callers, such as a young man who faced personal tragedies, received encouragement and pride from listeners through the social media group. The host highlights the touching comments made by community members, expressing their admiration and offering well wishes to the young caller. This narrative emphasizes the importance of communal empathy and how listeners connect with each other's real-life struggles.
Light-hearted Yet Tense Police Encounter
A tense yet humorous encounter occurs when the caller and his friends face a police stop while driving through Texas. After unintentionally speeding through a town, they encounter a Texas cop who smells something suspicious in their car, triggering a canine unit search. The caller candidly shares that they were carrying edibles and a small amount of weed, explaining their intentions to distribute among friends. Fortunately, the police let them off with just a ticket, and the caller reflects on their luck in avoiding serious repercussions, given the circumstances.
Strange Tattoo Story at Rite Aid
An amusing incident from the caller's high school job at Rite Aid emerges, where they encountered a customer wanting to print a large number of nude photos. The customer, aiming to create an album for her boyfriend, inadvertently handed over around 150 intimate pictures of herself. The caller, taken aback but professional, had to process the photos while ensuring the privacy of the customer. They humorously recount how they ultimately decided to shred the photos to prevent any potential issues, showcasing the oddities that can accompany customer service roles.
Nostalgic Reflections on New Jersey
The conversation flows into nostalgic reflections on growing up in New Jersey, where the caller reminisces about exploring abandoned places with friends. The dialogue delves into notable locations like the Devil's Tree and Gravity Road, illustrating a shared experience of youthful adventure. The connection to the comedic roots of New Jersey life is palpable as they discuss their mutual memories and how these experiences shaped their identities. The warmth of this shared background serves as a reminder of how our roots influence our present lives and relationships.
“I did have a murderer’s fingers in my mouth a couple times.” That’s how this week’s caller kicks things off, setting the tone for an episode filled with random and often darkly hilarious stories. He and Gethard play a morbid round of Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon, share their mutual appreciation for one of Jersey youths’ greatest and most time-honored traditions, and dive into tales of a frugal exhibitionist and a road trip that nearly ended in disaster.
Sign up for Beautiful/Anonymous+ to get ad free episodes and access to exclusive audio including 5 Random Questions with this week’s caller. Follow Beautiful/Anonymous on our new TikTok: @beautiful.anonymous Head to punchup.live/chrisgethard for tickets to That Show hosted by Gethard at UCB Theatre. Leave us a voicemail at (973) 306-4676