The Edition: Streeting vs Starmer, medical misinformation & the surprising history of phallic graffiti
Nov 21, 2024
auto_awesome
Katy Balls, Political editor at The Spectator, shares insights on Wes Streeting's controversial stance on assisted dying and its implications for Keir Starmer. Matt Ridley discusses the alarming rise of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. fueled by medical misinformation, while Sander van der Linden highlights the UK's vulnerability to such falsehoods. Meanwhile, Alka Pande explores the cultural significance of phallic graffiti, revealing its historical roots and contrasting perceptions between Western and Indian interpretations.
Wes Streeting's opposition to the assisted dying bill highlights internal Labour Party tensions and differing views on end-of-life care responsibilities.
The rise of medical misinformation exemplified by figures like RFK Jr. underscores the urgent need for transparency to rebuild public trust in science.
Deep dives
Wes Streeting's Stance on Assisted Dying
Wes Streeting, the health secretary, plans to vote against the assisted dying bill primarily due to concerns about the current state of palliative care. He believes that these services are inadequate to offer genuine choice to individuals facing end-of-life decisions. Streeting's opposition reflects broader debates within the Labour Party, where differing views on the matter may emerge as new MPs consider their positions. His comments have reignited discussions on assisted dying, particularly against the backdrop of a previous Parliament vote where Keir Starmer expressed support for legal changes.
The Political Dynamics of the Assisted Dying Vote
The impending vote on assisted dying has created political tensions within the Labour Party, especially regarding Keir Starmer's approach to the conscience issue. Starmer's previous alignment with changing the law contrasts with his current silence, which has led to speculation about his leadership efficacy. The vote is being pushed through a private member's bill, unexpectedly placing pressure on newly elected MPs to decide on a contentious issue. This unique political context means that many MPs are weighing the implications of their votes carefully, reflecting their constituents' sentiments while grappling with party loyalties.
Science Misinformation and Its Consequences
The rise of science misinformation has notably impacted figures like RFK Jr., who gained prominence during the COVID-19 pandemic, fueled by public distrust in authorities. His controversial views, stemming from a perceived authoritarian approach to health communication, have garnered a significant following, highlighting a broader skepticism towards medical expertise. Experts argue that this trend underscores a need for transparency and humility in the scientific community to rebuild the public's trust. This situation points to a crucial challenge in addressing misinformation and emphasizes the importance of open dialogue about scientific uncertainty.
Cultural Perspectives on Phallic Graffiti
Recent crude graffiti in Dulwich Wood has sparked discussions about the historical context and cultural perceptions surrounding phallic imagery. Linking this phenomena to ancient Roman practices, it's suggested that such expressions have existed for centuries, often devoid of the shock value seen in contemporary society. Interviews with experts reveal stark contrasts between Western and Eastern attitudes toward phallic symbols, particularly in India where they are often considered sacred rather than vulgar. This ongoing debate reflects broader themes in art, society, and changing cultural sensitivities regarding human sexuality and expression.
Ahead of next week’s vote on whether to legalise assisted dying, Health Secretary Wes Streeting is causing trouble for Keir Starmer, writes Katy Balls in the magazine this week. Starmer has been clear that he doesn’t want government ministers to be too outspoken on the issue ahead of a free vote in Parliament. But Streeting’s opposition is well-known. How much of a headache is this for Starmer? And does this speak to wider ambitions that Wes might have?
Katy joins the podcast to discuss, alongside Labour MP Steve Race. Steve explains why he plans to vote in favour of the change in the law next week (00:57).
Then: how concerned should we be about medical misinformation?
President-elect Donald Trump has announced vaccine sceptic Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as his pick for Secretary of Health and Human Services in the US. In the magazine this week, Matt Ridley explains that it’s not the man himself that’s as interesting, as the reasons how he has ended up in such a position: scientific misinformation has fuelled his rise. So how concerned should we be about medical misinformation? Firstly, Matt joined the podcast to explain his thesis and why reactions to the covid pandemic are to blame (16:24).
Later, Sander van der Linden, professor of social psychology at the University of Cambridge, also joins the podcast to discuss his concerns and how susceptible we are here in Britain to misinformation (23:46).
And finally: did you know that crude graffiti has a storied history?
Harry Mount examines the notorious penis gang that has appeared in Dulwich, daubing penises across trees. Whatever you think of such graffiti, scribbling phalluses, and even erotic art, are actually as old as time – from ancient Rome to India. What’s the line between graffiti and erotic art? And should Westerners be less prudish when confronted with these images? Harry joins the podcast alongside academic, and author of Pha(bu)llus: A Cultural History, Dr Alka Pande (30:50).
Hosted by William Moore and Lara Prendergast.
Produced by Patrick Gibbons.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode