Yanni Kotsonis, a Professor of History at NYU, dives deep into the Greek Revolution, a defining event that reshaped nationalism in the 19th century. He discusses how layers of imperialism and social upheaval led to Greece's independence. The complexities of nationalism are unpacked, alongside the unexpected emergence of revolutionary fervor among Greeks. Kotsonis also highlights the pivotal role of trade in forging Greek identity and reflects on the financial struggles that have persisted from the revolution to modern times.
The Greek Revolution not only led to Greece's independence but also catalyzed the rise of nationalism across the eastern Mediterranean and Europe.
A simplified historical narrative in Greece often glorified individual heroes, neglecting the collective complexities and broader historical contexts shaping the revolution.
Foreign powers significantly influenced the Greek Revolution, as their involvement and imperial interests shaped both local elite dynamics and the resultant state formation.
Deep dives
The Influence of the Greek Revolution
The Greek Revolution marked a significant turning point not only for Greece but also for the wider Eastern Mediterranean and Europe. It represented one of the early instances of nationalism leading to independence from the Ottoman Empire, setting a valuable precedent for other nationalist movements. This social upheaval included a range of events such as massacres and battles, which changed cultural perceptions and identities in the region, giving rise to the idea of an independent Greek national identity. The revolution acted as a catalyst in the formation of nationalism, emphasizing it as both an ideology and a method for achieving political autonomy.
Education and Historical Identity
Education and historical narrative played a key role in shaping the societal understanding of the Greek Revolution. Traditional histories, often taught within a parochial framework, glorified individual heroes while failing to integrate the complexities of collective historical experiences. Growing up in Greece, many individuals were exposed to a simplified version of events that excluded broader European contexts and developments. This narrow approach not only limited their understanding of history but also created challenges in recognizing the interconnectedness of national histories globally.
External Powers and Their Roles
The involvement of foreign powers was crucial during the Greek Revolution, impacting its outcome and the subsequent establishment of Greece as a state. The dynamics of international affairs at the time saw countries like Russia, France, and Britain playing pivotal roles, with each aiming to extend their influence in the region. The interferences of these powers orchestrated a balance where local elites leveraged foreign forces to secure their positions while also exploiting the revolutionary fervor for personal gain. This engagement with imperial bureaucracy demonstrated that the revolution was supported by a mixture of internal motivations and external pressures.
Economic Factors Driving the Revolution
Economic considerations emerged as a fundamental aspect propelling the Greek Revolution forward. The collection of taxes from the peasantry was historically managed by an elite class who sought to protect their interests during turbulent times, seeking the loyalty of the oppressed masses. As revolutionary sentiments grew, both sides of the conflict utilized economic mechanisms, with revolutionaries seizing property and wealth during uprisings, which intensified the struggle for power. This intertwining of revolutionary efforts with economic motivations revealed that the revolution was as much about material wealth as it was about national identity.
The Legacy of Nationalism
The Greek Revolution laid the groundwork for future interpretations of nationalism, establishing it as an ethnic-based ideology that would resonate beyond Greece's borders. This movement primarily focused on the notion of belonging to a singular nation defined by shared cultural and historical traits rather than civic nationalism. The challenges that arose from this nationalistic fervor led to a unique interplay of identities, impacting both Greek self-perception and their relationships with neighboring cultures. As the concept of a Greek nation solidified, it catalyzed similar nationalist movements throughout Europe, illustrating the ripple effects of the Greek Revolution across the continent.
If English speakers—or French speakers, or Spanish speakers, or really most any speaker of any language other than Greek…or Turkish—think about the Greek Revolution at all, then that’s amazing. If they do not, then they continue to ignore one of the most consequential collection of events in the 19th century, a series of imperial overlaps, social convulsions, massacres, sieges, expulsions, and sometimes battles that not only resulted in an independent Greece, but also changed forever the culture of the eastern Mediterranean, and birthed nationalism as a successful way of not only theorizing but of being.
My guest Yanni Kotsonis is Professor of History at New York University, where he was founding director of the Jordan Center for the Advanced Study of Russia. Raised in Athens, he was educated in Montreal, Copenhagen, London, and Moscow. His most recent book is The Greek Revolution and the Violent Birth of Nationalism, which is the subject of our conversation today.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode