Explore the growth of Liberation Theology in Latin America during the 1970s amidst guerrilla warfare and government repression. Learn about the rise of left-wing politics, the involvement of the church in the revolution, and the support received from religious orders and base communities.
The 1970s in Latin America was marked by the rise of left-wing movements and brutal right-wing dictatorships, leading to political tensions and violent repression.
Liberation theology emerged as a response to social and economic injustice in Latin America and called for a social revolution and the active participation of the church in the struggle for justice.
Deep dives
Liberation Struggles and Political Tensions in Latin America
During the 1970s in Latin America, there was a rise of left-wing movements and guerrilla warfare, as well as brutal right-wing dictatorships. Military takeovers occurred in several countries, leading to a repressive and violent period. The political situation in Chile, Peru, Argentina, and Uruguay exemplified the struggles, with groups like the Tupamaros and the Shining Path emerging. The left achieved a significant victory in Chile with Salvador Allende's election. However, military regimes suppressed opposition, leading to government-sponsored violence, disappearances, and human rights abuses. The only notable success for communist movements during this decade was the Sandinistas' takeover in Nicaragua, supported by the Soviet Union and Cuba. These political tensions provided the backdrop for the development and challenges faced by liberation theology in Latin America.
The Emergence and Influence of Liberation Theology
Liberation theology emerged as a response to the social and economic injustice experienced in Latin America. Influenced by the Second Vatican Council and the conference of Latin American bishops in Medellin in 1968, liberation theology sought to address the systemic oppression of the poor and marginalized. The movement emphasized the need for social revolution and advocated for a radical change in societal structures. Liberation theologians, such as Gustavo Gutierrez, called for the church to actively participate in the struggle for justice and to stand on the side of the oppressed. Through the establishment of base communities and the publication of influential books, like Gutierrez's 'A Theology of Liberation,' the movement gained momentum and support within the Catholic Church and received funding from various sources.
Opposition and Criticism of Liberation Theology
Despite the growing influence of liberation theology, it faced opposition and criticism from various quarters. Some conservative bishops, theologians, and intellectuals raised concerns about the movement's political activism and its interpretation of the Gospel. Criticism focused on liberation theologians reducing the concept of liberation to a political strategy and elevating social revolution over spiritual liberation from sin. Many opponents argued that the movement subordinated evangelization to political goals and jeopardized the supernatural aspects of Christian faith. These objections led to intellectual combat and internal battles within the Catholic Church, intensifying with the election of Pope John Paul II, who had a strongly anti-Marxist stance.
The Stalemate at the Conference of Latin American Bishops in Puebla
The Conference of Latin American Bishops meeting in Puebla became a battleground between proponents and opponents of liberation theology. While conservative forces like Alfonso Trujillo exerted control over participant selection and documents, a substantial number of progressive bishops managed to include liberation theology concerns in the final document. The conference reflected conflicting visions of the church's role in society and the need to address social injustice. However, the opposing sides left the conference believing they could shape the future of liberation theology. The stalemate highlighted the tensions and debates within the Catholic Church over the priorities and methods of addressing social issues and advocating for the oppressed.
In the third episode of our series on Liberation Theology, we look at the growth and expansion of the movement during the 1970s, even as an opposition arises in the Latin American hierarchy, amidst the backdrop of guerrilla warfare and brutal government repression that afflicts much of Latin America.