
Controversies in Church History
My name is Darrick Taylor, and I am the founder and proprietor of Controversies in Church History, a podcast that takes an in depth look at difficult, even disturbing, issues in the history of the Catholic Church. My perspective is unique, in that I am a faithful Roman Catholic, yet trained as a secular historian. Designed for Catholics but accessible for anyone interested in history, it balances storytelling with an academic sensibility.
Latest episodes

Apr 2, 2025 • 6min
Updates/Upcoming Episodes and Other Things
Hello! This is just a brief update on what's cooking for Controversies in Church History. Please take a listen, I have some good things in store for my followers. Cheers!

Mar 12, 2025 • 41min
Cloud of Witnesses: The Origins of the Cult of the Saints
When did the early Christians begin to seek the intercession of particularly holy people, such as the martyrs? Was this something they copied from Greco-Roman society? In the latest episode of Controversies in Church History, we take a look at the origins of the cult of the saints. In it, I discuss when and how the early Christians began to venerate Christian martyrs, and the evidence of this practice. I address the similarities and differences between the veneration of the saints and Greco-Roman religion, and why veneration of saints marked a radical departure from other religions in the ancient world.

Mar 2, 2025 • 26min
Church Musings: The Reformation as Elite Crisis
Hello! I thought I would drop a short, unscripted episode about something that has been on my mind recently, namely, elites. Inspired by an embarrassing situation in the Catholic Church in England, I muse on the theory of "elite overproduction" and how it might apply to the Protestant Reformation. Which means I geek out over the numbers of universities founded in late medieval Europe. If you like thinking about history, I hope this more speculative episode whets your appetites. Cheers!

Feb 18, 2025 • 57min
Christendom's Image Crisis: the Iconoclast Controversy, 724-843
Dive into the complex world of iconoclasm in the Byzantine Empire during the 8th and 9th centuries. Explore the clash between those who wanted to destroy sacred images and their passionate defenders. Discover how political, social, and theological factors influenced these intense debates. Learn about the historical evolution of image veneration from early Christian art to its eventual triumph. Uncover the pivotal role of Empress Theodora in restoring icon veneration and its lasting impact on Orthodox and Catholic teachings.

Jan 31, 2025 • 50min
Persecution, Schism and Genocide: the Trials of Armenian Catholics, c. 1700-1928 (Latinization X)
Discover the tumultuous journey of the Armenian Catholic Church within the Ottoman Empire, marked by persecution and suspicion from Rome. Explore the schism of the 1870s and the dire impact of nationalist movements. Delve into the internal conflicts sparked by conversions to Catholicism and the strains on traditional authority. The discussion takes a poignant turn as it reflects on the tragic events of the Armenian Genocide, linking historical struggles to the ongoing challenges faced by Christians in Syria today.

Jan 29, 2025 • 43min
What We've Been Reading: 2024 Edition
Discover fascinating insights as the host reviews a diverse array of thought-provoking books on theology, literature, and history. From traditional Catholic views on marriage and liturgy to the exploration of romanticism and Viktor Frankl's search for meaning, each work unravels rich themes. Delve into maritime history with tales of survival and mutiny, while also navigating the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The discussion highlights the importance of engaging with various perspectives on contemporary issues.

Jul 9, 2024 • 1h 17min
The Papacy and the Orthodox: an Interview with Erick Ybarra
Author and apologist, Erick Ybarra, discusses his book on the papacy and debates with the Orthodox Church. They explore historical controversies surrounding Pope Honorius and papal authority in the first millennium. The conversation also touches on the challenges of papal infallibility and maintaining respectful dialogue with the Orthodox Church.

Jun 16, 2024 • 6min
Upcoming Events: ICC Lecture & Interview with Erick Ybarra
Just a brief preview of some upcoming events I am involved in the next month or so, including the next Controversies in Church History interview. Cheers!

May 21, 2024 • 1h 11min
Chateaubriand and the Genius of Catholicism
The podcast explores the life and works of Francois Rene Chateaubriand, focusing on his apologetics work 'The Genius of Christianity'. They discuss the intersection of Christianity, Enlightenment criticisms, and Romanticism, as well as the superiority of Christian love over pagan love. The episode also delves into Chateaubriand's influence on Romanticism and apologetics, highlighting his perspective on liturgy and beauty.

Apr 16, 2024 • 51min
Latinization IX: The Papacy and the Eastern Churches, 1846-1958
Exploring the impact of the papacy on Eastern Catholic Churches from 1846-1958, discussing centralization and Latinization efforts. Challenges of reuniting with Eastern Churches, centralization efforts by various popes, and the support given by Benedict XV and Pius XII. Centralization's impact on Eastern Churches' representation at the Vatican and alignment with desires, with a preview of future episodes on Church history and Jordan Peterson.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.