087: Seculosity, Shared Suffering, and Why Men Need Their Own Space
Oct 14, 2024
auto_awesome
In this installment, Jason and Gabe chat with David Zahl, the founder of Mockingbird Ministries and a voice for young adults. They dive into the concept of 'seculosity,' how modern life mimics religious anxieties, and the rising need for men's spaces. David discusses the challenges men face with loneliness and careerism, while emphasizing the power of shared suffering. They also tackle modern parenting pressures, the messiness of college admissions, and the essentials of marital connection, reminding listeners that community and support are key in today’s world.
David Zahl introduces 'seculosity' as a modern anxiety reflected in secular pursuits that mimic traditional religious pressures.
The podcast discusses the importance of men's groups, like F3, in providing a vital sense of community and support amidst increasing isolation.
Parental anxieties stemming from contemporary parenting styles reveal a need for community and understanding in raising successful children.
Deep dives
The Evolving Role of Traditional Religion
The podcast delves into the apparent decline of traditional religion and explores how various secular institutions are taking its place. It highlights how fitness and careerism are becoming substitutes for the purpose and community that religion once provided. The conversation underscores the impact of this shift, suggesting that while some secular pursuits can foster well-being, they may also contribute to feelings of emptiness or pressure to perform. The speakers reflect on the mixed effects these changes have had on individuals, particularly men who may feel increasingly isolated in their search for meaning.
Seculosity and its Implications
David Zale introduces the concept of 'seculosity', describing it as a contemporary manifestation of religious-like anxieties found in everyday activities. He explains how seemingly secular trends, such as fitness and parenting philosophies, often carry underlying pressures akin to those found in traditional religious spheres. This can create a new form of anxiety as individuals seek validation and belonging within these secular frameworks. The discussion invokes thoughts on how these shifts complicate the pursuit of happiness and fulfillment in modern life.
The Dilemma of Masculinity
The dialogue touches on the struggles modern men face in navigating their identities amidst shifting societal expectations. The participants express concern that the church has struggled to address the unique challenges men encounter, resulting in a feeling of disconnection. They discuss how men's groups, like F3, provide essential community and support, allowing men to come together to exercise, share experiences, and foster genuine connections. This sense of belonging is highlighted as crucial for men, who may feel particularly isolated and lonely in today's culture.
Navigating Parenthood and Women's Roles
The speakers emphasize the complexities of parenthood, particularly how current parenting styles can evoke strong emotional charges and create tribes. The conversation expands to address the social pressures parents face, such as adherence to various parenting philosophies and the competition to raise successful children. Zale reflects on the tension between wanting the best for one's children and the anxiety that often accompanies these desires. This dynamic further highlights the need for community support and understanding in navigating the tumultuous waters of modern parenting.
The Search for Meaning Beyond Achievement
David Zale articulates the idea that excessive focus on career achievement often displaces other sources of meaning and fulfillment. He discusses how societal changes have narrowed young men’s outlook on career choices to a few lucrative fields, which can contribute to feelings of disposability and a lack of purpose. The conversation emphasizes the importance of fostering authentic human connections, shared experiences, and helping one another, especially among men. This sense of community is seen as essential to combatting feelings of loneliness and despair, grounding individuals in something meaningful beyond personal achievements.
Jason and Gabe sit down with David Zahl for today’s episode of the Jason Khalipa Podcast:
- Who is David Zahl?
- What is “seculosity,” and how did we get here?
- The religion of parenting.
- Is traditional religion declining?
- How has the church let men down?
- The magic of fitness men’s clubs.
- Men need a space to be themselves.
- Shared suffering goes a long way.
- What makes THMC / F3 so unique?
- There is no silver bullet for contemporary loneliness.
- Careerism is a huge problem in the U.S.
- When men are thriving, they WANT to help.
- Why is the college admissions process such a mess?
- Marriage comes first! Date night is everything!
Never let momentum get to zero. Listen to the Jason Khalipa Podcast every Monday and Thursday on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube.