Wisdom of Crowds

The Secrets and Sorrows of Gay Washington

Jun 24, 2022

Discover the triumph and sorrow of the gay experience in Washington DC, from the red scare to the closet opening, examining the impact of the national security state, progress in politics, and the lasting legacy of the gay rights movement.

48:12

Creator website

Episode guests

Jamie Kirchick

AI Summary

AI Chapters

Episode notes

Podcast summary created with Snipd AI

Quick takeaways

The podcast highlights the struggles of gay individuals working in government amidst fears of losing jobs and personal safety.

The evolution of societal attitudes towards homosexuality is discussed, emphasizing the progress in legal rights despite persisting homophobia.

Deep dives

Evolution of Gay Identity

The podcast delves into the evolution of gay identity, tracing it back to the late 19th century when the term homosexual was coined, indicating a shift from seeing it as an action to an identity. The narrative explores how World War II played a crucial role in shaping gay consciousness by bringing individuals of varying backgrounds together and fostering a sense of commonality. Post-war developments such as gay literature and the Kinsey Report further contributed to the visibility and understanding of diverse sexual experiences.

Introduction

5min

Homosexuality in the National Security State

7min

Impact of the Kinsey Study on American Perceptions of Homosexuality

2min

Exploring Historical Perceptions of Homosexuality and Communism

19min

Exploring Historical Context and Progress in the US

12min

The Evolution of Public Opinion on Homosexuality

4min

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit wisdomofcrowds.live

Jamie Kirchick joins us to discuss the triumph and sorrow of the gay experience in the nation's capitol. This is the story of The Secret City, Kirchick's genre-defining and panoramic history of the gay men and women who served in the halls of power, all the while in constant fear that they would lose their jobs and perhaps even their lives.

It got worse before it got better. We discuss how the national security state—born after World War II—both brought down immense suffering upon countless individuals (including in a string of shocking suicides), and helped shape the consciousness of the country as a whole. There was the red scare, but there was also the "pink scare," with fears of political perversion driving fears of sexual perversion and vice-versa. But was there progress in the end?

The Reagan Administration, despite its homophobia and failures to act on AIDS, could also claim perhaps the largest number of gay political appointees up until that point in U.S. history. And then the closet began to open, so much so that it is difficult to imagine just how horrific it was mere decades ago for gays serving in government. But is this really "progress"—and does it mean we should be optimistic about America's future, despite everything?

In the full episode (for subscribers), we dig deeper into just how lasting the triumphs of the gay rights movement will be. On one hand, homosexuality has become so normalized that no one (except radical gender activists) even thinks twice about Pete Buttigieg running for national office. On the other, the culture war over trans rights is taking a nasty turn, with room for dissent rapidly closing. We debate whether the LGBTQ+ community can stay united in victory, and whether Queer ideology is actually homophobic.

Required Reading:

- Secret City: The Hidden History of Gay Washington, by Jamie Kirchick.

- "The Long, Sordid History of the Gay Conspiracy," by Jamie Kirchick (New York Magazine).

- "The Struggle for Gay Rights is Over," by Jamie Kirchick (The Atlantic).

- Notes on Camp, by Susan Sontag.

- Virtually Normal: An Argument About Homosexuality, by Andrew Sullivan.

- Masha Gessen on Judith Butler (New Yorker).