‘They don't know much’: Politicians spending on the military
Feb 25, 2024
auto_awesome
Debating the effectiveness of Australia's naval ship procurement plans, the Albanese government's ambitious naval fleet overhaul, concerns over rising military expenditure, and the importance of informed defense strategies for national security.
Australia faces delays in acquiring new navy ships due to changing government plans.
Investing in expensive surface ships raises concerns about their vulnerability and strategic necessity.
Deep dives
Australia's Expensive Naval Plans
Australia has been struggling for nearly 15 years to acquire new surface ships for its navy, facing cost escalations and delays in the process. The Albanese government recently revealed plans for the navy's surface fleet, expected to cost significantly more than initial estimates. Despite already investing billions, the government is moving forward with additional projects involving new classes of surface ships, raising concerns about aligning spending with actual defense needs.
Vulnerabilities of Surface Ships
The announcement of expanding the Royal Australian Navy's fleet includes the procurement of various types of ships, such as general purpose frigates and large surface vessels. However, surface ships are exposed to multiple vulnerabilities, including being targeted by modern weaponry like torpedoes, missiles launched from various platforms, and sea mines. The high value of ships makes them attractive targets, posing challenges for their survivability in high-intensity warfare scenarios.
Strategic and Fiscal Concerns
Questions arise regarding the necessity and strategic coherence of Australia's substantial investments in naval capabilities. While considering potential conflicts with major powers like China, there is uncertainty about the practicality and effectiveness of the current defense spending choices. The lack of a clear military strategy guiding expenditures coupled with the complexities of managing defense projects contribute to inefficiencies and risks in Australia's defense planning.
Australia has spent almost 15 years trying to buy new surface ships for the navy, but they are still yet to arrive.
That’s because governments have repeatedly thrown out the old plan to introduce their own.
Last week, the Albanese government was the latest to reveal their plans for the future of the navy’s surface fleet. So, will it work?
Today, emeritus professor of strategic studies at the Australian National University and contributor to The Saturday Paper Hugh White, on Labor’s navy overhaul and whether it’s an expensive grab for votes.