Jeffrey Morgenthaler, cocktail expert and creator of the Best Amaretto Sour In the World, talks about the evolution of sour mix, beating egg whites, and the resurgence of liqueurs in cocktails. He shares his Amaretto Sour recipe and discusses the history and perception of the cocktail. The hosts also discuss characteristics of Beam whiskies, using fresh egg whites, preparation and ingredients of the cocktail, and techniques for lemon twists. They also recommend books and discuss favorite movie scenes involving bartenders.
Creating a modern classic Amaretto Sour by using strong bourbon, fresh lemon juice, and egg white.
Morgenthaler's appreciation for Scotch whiskey and its unique flavors and profiles.
Recommendation of Toby Cecchini's book, Cosmopolitan, as a must-read for alcohol and cocktail enthusiasts.
Deep dives
The Amaretto Sour and its Evolution
The podcast episode explores the Amaretto Sour, a classic cocktail that has received a contemporary spin from bartender Jeffrey Morgenthaler. He shares his journey of creating the perfect Amaretto Sour and how he used strong bourbon, fresh lemon juice, and egg white to enhance the flavor and balance of the drink. Morgenthaler's version of the Amaretto Sour has gained recognition as a modern classic.
The Appeal of Scotch Whiskey
Morgenthaler expresses his excitement for Scotch whiskey, particularly enjoying its unique flavors and profiles. He mentions his preference for cast strength Scotch, highlighting the chocolatey, peanut, and caramel notes found in some expressions. Morgenthaler describes Scotch whiskey as one of humankind's finest achievements and encourages enthusiasts to explore the wide range of options available.
Toby Cecchini's Cosmopolitan
Morgenthaler recommends Toby Cecchini's book, Cosmopolitan, as an essential read for alcohol and cocktail enthusiasts. He praises the book for its portrayal of the bartender's profession and the insight it provides into the industry. Morgenthaler notes that the book offers a unique perspective and voice that captures the essence of being a bartender.
The Scene from Good Will Hunting
Morgenthaler chooses the bar scene from Good Will Hunting as a movie moment he'd like to appear in. He mentions the thought-provoking dialogue between the characters and the memorable lines delivered by Matt Damon's character, Will Hunting. Morgenthaler envisions playing the role of a bartender in the background, observing the engaging conversation and providing subtle presence to the scene.
The Unique Contribution of the Amaretto Sour
Morgenthaler suggests that the Amaretto Sour, particularly his own version, deserves more recognition as a modern classic cocktail. He highlights its smooth, silky mouthfeel and the celebration of the amaretto flavor. Morgenthaler believes that the drink challenges the notion that certain cocktails are superior to others, emphasizing that there are no bad drinks, only bad bartenders.
Examining another branch of the sour cocktail family, we're joined today by friend of the show Jeffrey Morgenthaler of Portland’s Pacific Standard to talk about his self-proclaimed “Best Amaretto Sour In the World.” We will also look at the evolution of sour mix, the subtle art of beating egg whites, and the exciting resurgence of liqueurs in the cocktail space. Listen on to discover Morgenthaler’s Amaretto Sour recipe — and don’t forget to like, review, and subscribe!
Jeffrey Morgenthaler's Amaretto Sour Recipe
Ingredients
1 teaspoon of rich simple syrup (2:1)
½ ounce lightly beaten egg white
1 ounce of lemon juice
¾ ounce of cask-strength bourbon
1 ½ ounces of Amaretto
Garnish: Lemon peel, brandied cherry
Directions
Add all ingredients to a shaker with several large ice cubes.
Shake until chilled.
Strain into a 10-ounce Old Fashioned glass.
Top with ice and garnish with a lemon twist and a brandied cherry on a toothpick, tucked into the lemon peel.