Why the "Need for Chaos" Is Eating American Politics
Mar 1, 2024
auto_awesome
Unveiling the 'Need for Chaos' Mentality in American Politics, exploring Americans' embrace of conspiracy theories due to extreme cynicism towards elites and power institutions. Guest Michael Bang Petersen discusses the darker aspects of political psychology and the prevalence of this mindset across the political spectrum. Exploring the impact of trust in elites on public sentiment, raising concerns about exploitation of public frustrations. Navigating social exclusion and inequality in political discourse to prevent radicalization. Exploring motivations behind sharing misinformation and chaos in society, linking it to societal inequalities and status competitions.
Americans embrace conspiracy theories due to a 'need for chaos' rooted in cynicism towards elite institutions.
The 'need for chaos' is a psychological motivation arising from feelings of social exclusion and status insecurity.
Deep dives
The Discovery of the Need for Chaos
Researchers conducted a study led by political scientist Michael Bang Peterson to understand why Americans shared conspiracy theories online. Contrary to expectations of typical polarization, a significant group emerged that shared any conspiracy, regardless of party bias. This group, defined by the 'need for chaos,' showed a willingness to circulate disruptive theories about figures from different political spectrums.
Defining the Need for Chaos
The 'need for chaos' was identified as a psychological motivation rooted in feelings of being stuck or marginalized in the current societal hierarchy. Individuals embracing this concept wished to tear down existing systems due to a perceived inability to progress within them, epitomizing a destructive impulse for change. The prevalence of this mindset varied, with around 5% displaying an extreme inclination towards chaos and up to 30% exhibiting some degree of its characteristics.
Addressing the Impact of Economic Inequality and Elite Failures
The rise of the chaos cohort was linked to both real and perceived elite failures, especially post-pandemic. The theory suggests that responses to chaos might stem from a reaction to social exclusion and status insecurity, prevalent among young men, notably white and black cohorts. Among white men, the fear of status loss triggered heightened aggression and a stronger embrace of chaos for change, reflecting broader societal issues such as economic inequality.
Today’s episode is about one of the most interesting pieces of research I’ve read in the past year. It's an idea called "need for chaos," and the truth is that I literally cannot stop thinking about it as I follow American culture, politics, and media. Very briefly, it is the observation that many Americans today embrace conspiracy theories and nihilistic burn-it-all-down messages, not because they are partisans of the left or right, but rather because they've become hopelessly cynical (sometimes for very good reason!) about all elite and all major institutions of power. Today’s guest is the Danish political scientist Michael Bang Petersen, who coauthored the paper that introduced this idea.
If you have questions, observations, or ideas for future episodes, email us at PlainEnglish@Spotify.com.