A Fitbit Helped Solve This Murder?! The Case of Nicole VanderHeyden
Jan 9, 2025
auto_awesome
Discover the tragic story of Nicole VanderHeyden, a dedicated mother whose life was cut short. Tensions rose during a chaotic night out, leading to her mysterious disappearance. The investigation took a surprising turn when Fitbit data and DNA evidence helped unravel the case. Explore the complex dynamics between Nicole and her boyfriend, and see how technology played a pivotal role in solving the mystery. The trial's shocking revelations leave a lasting impact on her family and friends.
FitBit data played a crucial role in exonerating Nikki's boyfriend while revealing DNA evidence that shifted the investigation to a different suspect.
Nikki's relationship with Doug showcased alarming signs of emotional distress and abuse, raising awareness about the impact of domestic violence.
The case exemplifies the importance of community support, as efforts continue to provide educational opportunities for Nikki's children in her absence.
Deep dives
Nikki's Background and Passion for Teaching
Nicole, also known as Nikki, was born on March 29, 1995, and raised in Wisconsin. She was loved by her family, which included her three siblings, and became a devoted mother. After graduating from high school, she earned a bachelor's degree in science and education, which allowed her to pursue her passion for teaching. Nikki was described as an enthusiastic educator who had a genuine interest in her students' success, particularly enjoying biology, and this passion translated into the positive impact she had on many young lives.
The Troubled Relationship with Doug Dietry
Nikki's relationship with Doug Dietry became complicated when she discovered she was pregnant shortly after they began dating. Despite the excitement of having a child together, the relationship was marked by emotional distress and perceived abuse, with Nikki's friends and family expressing concerns about Doug's behavior. Their relationship deteriorated further when they went out with friends one night, during which Doug abandoned Nikki, leading to a series of alarming text exchanges that displayed her anger and concern for her safety. The night ended tragically, as Nikki was last seen leaving the bar in a distressed state.
The Discovery of Nikki's Body
Nikki was reported missing after she failed to come home following a night out, prompting her boyfriend Doug to call 911. Earlier that day, a passerby stumbled upon what turned out to be Nikki's body in a field, leading authorities to suspect a connection between Doug's report and the discovery. Police were wary of Doug's delayed report and soon began to question him about the events surrounding Nikki's disappearance. As they investigated further, they uncovered blood and other evidence indicating a violent end to Nikki’s life, raising suspicion about Doug's involvement.
The Arrest and Trial of George Birch
While initial suspicion fell on Doug, the investigations soon turned toward George Birch after DNA evidence linked him to the crime. Birch's connections to the bars Nikki frequented, combined with his violent history, painted him as a potential suspect. The trial revealed how Birch's phone data placed him at crucial locations related to Nikki's murder, and his DNA was found on her body and the ligature used for strangulation. Ultimately, the evidence led to Birch’s conviction for murder, and he was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Aftermath and Legacy
In the wake of Nikki's tragic murder, her family and children continue to deal with the profound loss left in her absence. Doug, while cleared of murder, faced legal troubles related to other incidents after Nikki's death, raising ongoing concerns about his character. Efforts have been made to support Nikki's children financially, including fundraising efforts aimed at providing them with educational opportunities. Nikki's story highlights the importance of awareness regarding domestic violence and the lasting impacts of such tragedies on families.
In May 2016, 31 year-old Nicole VanderHeyden, a mom of three, was found dead in a field. Initially, her boyfriend was suspected as they had been in a fight, but his FitBit data showed that he was elsewhere during the murder. That's when they realized someone else's DNA was on Nicole's body.
This episode is sponsored by: Rocket Money SKIMS - select “podcast” in the survey and select our show in the dropdown menu that follows! Nutrafol - promo code: KENDALLRAE