The McShay Show CFP First Round Live Reactions: Miami, Alabama, Ole Miss and Oregon Advance | The McShay Show
Dec 21, 2025
In this engaging discussion, college football analyst Steve Muench breaks down the thrilling first-round matchups of the College Football Playoffs. The duo highlights Miami's surprising upset over Texas A&M, focusing on their impactful defense and emerging young talents like Malachi Tony. They also analyze Alabama's momentum swing in their victory against Oklahoma, emphasizing quarterback performances and how these playoff games could influence future draft decisions. Packed with insights, this breakdown is a must-listen for football fans!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Miami's Defense Carried The Day
- Miami won 10-3 by leaning on a dominant defense and an efficient run game led by Mark Fletcher Jr.
- Carson Beck played conservatively and avoided turnovers, which was the decisive factor in a low-scoring game.
Marcel Reed Was The X-Factor
- Todd McShay and Steve Muench identified Marcel Reed's turnovers as a recurring, decisive vulnerability for Texas A&M.
- Reed's late interceptions repeatedly cost A&M in tight defensive games against quality opponents.
Fletcher Shaped Miami's Identity
- Mark Fletcher Jr. rushed for 172 yards on 17 carries and gave Miami a clear identity in the game.
- Miami's run commitment and defensive front forced Texas A&M into mistakes and third-and-longs.