The McShay Show

In a dynamic discussion, college football analyst Steve Muench dives into Alabama QB Ty Simpson's surprising decision to declare for the 2026 NFL draft. Steve shares insights on Simpson’s impressive processing skills and concerns about his deep ball accuracy. They debate whether skipping another collegiate season was the right move, comparing Simpson's potential to past QBs like Mac Jones and Mitchell Trubisky. Best landing spots are hyped, including intriguing fits with the Rams and Dolphins. Will this gamble pay off? Tune in for expert analysis!

Join draft analyst Steve Muench as he dives into the thrilling world of NFL mock drafts. He breaks down the Raiders' pivotal QB decisions, comparing Dante Moore and Fernando Mendoza's prospects. The discussion heats up around whether a running back, such as Jeremiyah Love, should shine in the top three picks. Muench argues for the early demand of offensive tackles, while analyzing the key selections for top teams like the Giants and Bengals. Tune in for expert insights on positional trends and predictions shaping the upcoming draft!

Join Todd McShay and football analyst Steve Muench, a savvy interpreter of game strategies and draft insights, as they reflect on thrilling CFP quarterfinals. They dissect Ole Miss's shocking upset of Georgia, spotlight Miami's defensive prowess against Ohio State, and commend Indiana's commanding victory over Alabama. Muench also highlights Kurt Cignetti's impactful coaching and the NFL potential of players like Dante Moore. With Oregon's dominant shutout of Texas Tech, expect exhilarating discussions about upcoming semifinals and draft narratives!

Steve Muench, a football analyst and contributor, joins Todd McShay to dive into the intriguing world of the 2025 NFL redraft. They debate Tennessee's choice of QB Tyler Shough as the top pick and discuss edge rusher Abdul Carter’s potential for the Jaguars. The duo analyzes a tackle decision for the Patriots, weighing Will Campbell against Kelvin Banks Jr. They also highlight strategic selections by the Jets and Dolphins while exploring the best fits and surprising picks, providing a fascinating look at team needs and player value.

Dive into the exciting world of NFL draft prospects as Todd and Steve unveil their inaugural All-McShay Show Team. Discover standout players like quarterback Dante Moore and running back Jeremiyah Love. They highlight top wide receivers, including Denzel Boston and Makai Lemon, while discussing Kenyon Sadiq as the leading tight end. The duo explores red star under-the-radar talents and debates their favorite interior linemen. With insights on linebackers and cornerbacks, this is a must-listen for draft enthusiasts!

In this engaging discussion, college football analyst Steve Muench breaks down the thrilling first-round matchups of the College Football Playoffs. The duo highlights Miami's surprising upset over Texas A&M, focusing on their impactful defense and emerging young talents like Malachi Tony. They also analyze Alabama's momentum swing in their victory against Oklahoma, emphasizing quarterback performances and how these playoff games could influence future draft decisions. Packed with insights, this breakdown is a must-listen for football fans!

Joel Klatt, a Fox Sports college football analyst, joins the discussion to preview the thrilling College Football Playoff matchups. The team dives into the draft prospects of underclassmen Dante Moore and Ty Simpson, weighing their options with humor and insight. Klatt breaks down how Alabama's offense has struggled, while Oklahoma’s defense is stepping up. They also debate the dark horse potential of Oregon and preview key games, highlighting the strategic shift towards controlled, defensive play. Expect engaging debates and sharp insights throughout!

Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by reacting to the latest transfer portal news on DJ Lagway, Aidan Chiles, and LaNorris Sellers. Then, they take a look at the College Football Playoff field and draft the QBs they’re most confident in ahead of Friday’s first-round matchup between Alabama and Oklahoma.0:00 Welcome to The McShay Show!0:38 Todd's latest Intel and transfer portal news10:52 2025 CFP QB Confidence Draft20:30 Pick 1 (McShay): Fernando Mendoza, Indiana22:20 Pick 2 (Muench): Dante Moore, Oregon25:03 MY GUYS!26:45 Pick 3 (McShay): Gunner Stockton, Georgia31:56 Pick 4 (Muench): Julian Sayin, Ohio State36:35 Pick 5 (McShay): Carson Beck, Miami40:47 Pick 6 (Muench): Ty Simpson, Alabama42:37 Pick 7: (McShay): Behren Morton, Texas Tech47:13 Pick 8: (Muench): Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss48:32 Pick 9: (McShay): John Mateer, Oklahoma + Pick 10: (Muench): Marcel Reed, Texas A&M52:57  Pick 11: (McShay): Jake Retzlaff, Tulane + Pick 12: (Muench): Alonza Barnett III, JMU57:57 Join us this weekend live reacting to the CFP matchupsSubscribe to The McShay Report for access to all of Todd’s mock drafts, big boards, scouting reports, and more throughout the college football season.The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit www.rg-help.com to learn more about the resources and helplines available.Learn more and join waitlist at ScoutMotors.comHost: Todd McShayGuest: Steve MuenchProducers: Tucker Tashjian, Conor Nevins, and Daniel ComerSocial: Jon Roemer Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Welcome back to The McShay Show! Todd and Steve open by revealing the top 10 players on their rough draft big boards. Then, they hop into a quick flash mock to see how the first 10 picks might play out if the draft were tomorrow. To close, the guys are joined by former Eagles exec and cap expert Jake Rosenberg to discuss the future of college football and his new role with the Athlete Group. 0:00 Welcome to The McShay Show!3:45 Rough Draft: Top 10 Draft Prospects right now9:23 #1: Fernando Mendoza, Indiana QB9:40 #2: Arvell Reese, Ohio State LB10:02 #3: Dante Moore, Oregon QB13:00 #4: Jeremiyah Love, Notre Dame RB13:55 #5: Caleb Downs, Ohio State DS18:40 #6-#8: WR's Carnell Tate, Makai Lemon, Jordyn Tyson19:40 #9: Keldric Faulk, Auburn EDGE19:55 #10: Francis Mauigoa, Miami OT21:20 Takeaways from Todd's Top 10 Prospects23:40 FLASH MOCK!32:50 Browns trade up and draft Fernando Mendoza36:35 Raiders draft Dante Moore37:07 Titans draft Arvell Reese37:45 Giants draft Spencer Fano39:40 Saints draft Keldric Faulk42:00 Commanders draft Carnell Tate43:45 Jets draft Peter Woods45:10 Cardinals draft Jeremiyah Love45:35 Rams draft Caleb Downs47:13 Bengals draft David Bailey51:40 Jake Rosenberg joins the show next!59:28 Jake Rosenberg joins the show!59:35 How College Football front offices are built1:00:35 Jake's role in CFB program building1:06:33 CFB's growing needs for NFL style front office structuring1:10:32 How has CFB changed with the new role of General Managers1:16:35 How are CFB programs conducting their head coaching searches?1:18:33 What to look for in CFB General Managers?1:24:35 Are CFB programs resistant to change?1:30:40 Balancing players physical evaluations vs. financial valuations1:39:45 Managing portal vs. recruiting for programs1:45:30 How much does it cost for a CFB team to be competitive? Subscribe to The McShay Report for access to all of Todd’s mock drafts, big boards, scouting reports, and more throughout the college football season. The Ringer is committed to responsible gaming. Please visit www.rg-help.com to learn more about the resources and helplines available. Learn more and join waitlist at https://ScoutMotors.com.com Host: Todd McShayGuest: Steve MuenchProducers: Tucker Tashjian, Conor Nevins, and Daniel ComerSocial: Jon Roemer Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Todd McShay welcomes college football analyst Steve Muench for a lively dive into the College Football Playoff selection. They express frustration with playoff governance and discuss the implications of the ACC's poor season. Highlights include debating whether Notre Dame, Miami, and Alabama belong in the final rankings and reacting to live revelations about the seeds. They analyze Miami's surprising inclusion, critique Tulane's resume, and outline tactical matchups for upcoming games. Their insightful predictions leave listeners eager for the playoffs!