The Commentary Magazine Podcast Who's Being Isolated?
11 snips
Nov 17, 2025 James Kirchick, a journalist and author known for his insightful commentary on American politics, dives deep into the complexities of modern conservatism. He analyzes the isolationist sentiments within the American Conservative, particularly in response to Donald Trump's foreign policy. Kirchick discusses how these isolationist views can tip into antisemitism, and he traces their ideological roots back to figures like Pat Buchanan. The conversation sheds light on the recent resignation of Robert P. George from the Heritage Foundation, reflecting broader tensions within the GOP.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Isolationism Revives Around Buchanan
- The American Conservative has pivoted to praise Pat Buchanan and revive paleoconservative isolationism.
- That movement treats Israel and 'neocons' as the driving explanation for U.S. global engagement.
Isolationism Slips Into Anti‑Semitic Narratives
- Contemporary U.S. isolationism often morphs into anti-Semitic explanations for American foreign policy.
- Critics argue Israel and Jewish influence become the scapegoat for opposition to interventionism.
Israel Becomes The Center Of Foreign‑Policy Grievance
- The anti-intervention argument is being reframed to claim U.S. policy serves Israel above other interests.
- This reframing fuels the American Conservative's obsessive focus on Israel over other strategic partnerships.
