

Episode 312: Kimmel Complications
8 snips Sep 19, 2025
Rich and Andy delve into the Jimmy Kimmel controversy, discussing the fallout from his monologue and the implications of FCC threats on free speech. They explore two intriguing criminal cases, highlighting Tyler Robinson's defense strategy amid serious charges and the surprising drop of terrorism charges against Luigi Mangioni. This mix of pop culture and legal drama keeps the conversation both engaging and thought-provoking.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Kimmel Misstep And Media Motives
- Andy McCarthy and Rich Lowry argue Kimmel's monologue was factually wrong given then-known information about the suspect.
- They see media tribalism and business motives both driving late-night commentary and backlash.
Business Incentives Shape Programming
- Andy McCarthy suggests networks may use controversies as excuses to cut costly programming.
- He links ratings decline and profit motives to decisions about hosts like Kimmel.
Keep Regulators Out Of Editorial Pressure
- Avoid government regulators publicly threatening media outlets because it risks First Amendment harms.
- Let marketplace and affiliates respond organically instead of regulators using leverage to influence content.