

The McCarthy Report
National Review
American freedom is secured by the commitment of our courts and our people to the rule of law. The McCarthy Report offers listeners in-depth analysis on the most pressing legal questions facing the country. Alongside NATIONAL REVIEW editor in chief Rich Lowry, veteran prosecutor and law professor Andy McCarthy leverages his decades of legal experience to cut through the noise of media hysteria with sober-minded, thoughtful commentary.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Nov 19, 2025 • 55min
Episode 320: MBS Comes Calling
A Saudi visit to the White House sparks discussions on U.S.-Saudi relations and the Khashoggi crisis. The hosts debate the strategic necessity of engaging with Saudi Arabia despite human rights concerns. The podcast also dives into the congressional vote on releasing Epstein documents and its implications for due process. Additionally, a fresh ruling on Texas redistricting highlights political stakes and the Supreme Court's potential influence. Legal arguments around James Comey's prosecution add another layer to the captivating political landscape.

17 snips
Nov 14, 2025 • 49min
Episode 319: The Epstein File Dump Continues
The hosts delve into the newly released Epstein files, exploring their potential political ramifications. They discuss emails suggesting Trump's knowledge of Epstein’s activities but argue there's insufficient evidence connecting him to any crimes. A debate on transparency versus grand jury secrecy unfolds, as they highlight the influence of political motives in disclosure demands. The conversation shifts to Lindsey Halligan's appointment hearing and the possible implications of an invalid interim U.S. Attorney, raising questions about future indictments.

6 snips
Nov 7, 2025 • 1h 1min
Episode 318: SCOTUS Takes on the Tariffs
This discussion dives into the Supreme Court's oral arguments on Trump's tariffs, revealing the implications for executive power and trade policy. The hosts explore the historical challenges of legislative oversight and how recent election outcomes reflect public backlash against lawfare. They also analyze Dick Cheney's legacy in national security and counterterrorism post-9/11. Plus, there’s insight into the potential for the Comey indictment to face statutory hurdles. Tune in for a thought-provoking conversation packed with legal and political analysis!

7 snips
Oct 30, 2025 • 1h 2min
Episode 317: Pardon Protestations
The hosts dive into the ongoing sports betting scandal, unraveling how legalization has shifted incentives in the game. They also discuss the controversy around Biden's autopen usage and its constitutional implications. Another gripping topic is the legal challenges surrounding the deployment of the National Guard in Chicago. Additional insights emerge on U.S. actions in Venezuela, weighing the legality of targeting drug boats and the complexities of potentially seizing Maduro. It's a whirlwind of legal, political, and sports intrigue!

8 snips
Oct 22, 2025 • 47min
Episode 316: Reimbursement Request
Rich and Andy dive into Trump's controversial DOJ reimbursement request, examining its implications on the 2020 narrative. They tackle the Bolton indictment, highlighting issues around unsecured emails and classified material. The duo explores the concept of lawfare, identifying politically driven prosecutions and the historical context of classified information controversies. With anecdotes from baseball and reflections on congressional power, the discussion reveals the intricate connection between politics and law in contemporary America.

8 snips
Oct 9, 2025 • 59min
Episode 315: Peace Plan Potential
The hosts dive into the nuances of Trump's tentative peace plan for the Middle East, analyzing Hamas's response and the role of Turkey and Qatar in mediation. They explore the implications of National Guard deployments in Portland and Chicago, highlighting the legal complexities involved. The discussion shifts to the recent arraignment of James Comey, examining procedural issues and potential motions. Lastly, they unpack the controversial missile strikes against suspected drug boats in the Caribbean, questioning the legal framing of narcotics as armed conflict.

7 snips
Oct 1, 2025 • 1h 2min
Episode 314: Indictment Intricacies
The hosts dive into the nuances of Comey's indictment, clarifying legal terms like false statements and perjury. They speculate about the identities of key figures in the indictment, highlighting possibly significant issues tied to Hillary Clinton. Discussion shifts to Trump's ambitious 21-point plan for Gaza, with skepticism about its feasibility. Regional dynamics involving Qatar and Turkey's roles are examined, alongside a debate on presidential military powers without Congressional approval. It's a lively mix of legal analysis and political commentary!

Sep 25, 2025 • 1h 1min
Episode 313: Another Ill-Advised Indictment
Today on The McCarthy Report, Andy and Rich discuss Trump's pursuit of James Comey through lawfare, Letitia James news, what's going on with Tom Homan, and much more.
This podcast was edited and produced by Sarah Colleen Schutte. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

8 snips
Sep 19, 2025 • 47min
Episode 312: Kimmel Complications
Rich and Andy delve into the Jimmy Kimmel controversy, discussing the fallout from his monologue and the implications of FCC threats on free speech. They explore two intriguing criminal cases, highlighting Tyler Robinson's defense strategy amid serious charges and the surprising drop of terrorism charges against Luigi Mangioni. This mix of pop culture and legal drama keeps the conversation both engaging and thought-provoking.

12 snips
Sep 12, 2025 • 1h 2min
Episode 311: An Awful Week
The podcast delves into the recent assassination attempt on Charlie Kirk, raising questions about investigative secrecy and FBI accountability. It explores due process challenges related to the death penalty, contrasting state and federal approaches. The discussion highlights flaws in North Carolina’s bail system using the tragic case of DeCarlos Brown as a focal point. Mental health's intersection with justice is examined through a case involving 911 misuse. Additionally, the rising crime rates in Memphis are scrutinized, alongside the National Guard's role in enhancing security.


