Toby Stuart, a Distinguished Professor at UC Berkeley and author of 'Anointed', delves into the hidden dynamics of social status and its powerful influence on success. He discusses how small advantages lead to significant outcomes and examines the concept of the Matthew Effect in academia. The conversation dives into how status impacts personal identity, shapes societal perceptions, and raises questions about meritocracy in an AI-driven world. Toby also addresses the challenges of navigating social hierarchies and the implications for innovation and credibility.
55:25
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Status As A Necessary Filter
Status helps us navigate infinite choices by curating what we see and trust.
That curation is necessary but also concentrates opportunities unequally across people.
insights INSIGHT
Status Compounds Advantages
Status acts as a resource that begets other resources and opportunities.
Small early advantages often compound into large inequalities unrelated to merit.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Why Book Blurbs Exist
Toby describes why blurbs exist: they signal quality when buyers lack information about the book's content.
Readers rely on the who (author or blurber) when they can't assess the what.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Welcome to episode #1001 of Thinking With Mitch Joel (formerly Six Pixels of Separation).
Toby Stuart is a Distinguished Professor of Business Administration at the Haas School of Business, UC Berkeley, where he directs the Berkeley-Haas Entrepreneurship Program and the Institute for Business Innovation. Over his career, he has also taught at Harvard, Columbia, Chicago Booth and MIT Sloan, and he is recognized globally as one of the leading thinkers on entrepreneurship, networks and organizational strategy. Beyond academia, Toby sits on the boards of multiple technology companies, cofounded the Black Venture Institute, and serves as the founding Chairman of Workday’s AI Advisory Board. His latest book, Anointed - The Extraordinary Effects Of Social Status In A Winner-Take-Most World, examines the invisible hierarchies that govern so much of human life and why small advantages so often compound into massive outcomes. From why blurbs on books sway readers, to how neighborhoods or technologies become “the next big thing,” to the inequalities embedded in who gets credit for innovation, Anointed reveals how status shapes trust, opportunity and even our sense of self (I loved this book). Toby argues that status is both necessary - helping us navigate infinite choices in the modern world - and corrosive, creating inequality that is often disconnected from true merit. In our discussion, Toby unpacks the mechanics of anointment, the ways status rubs off through association and how technology, especially AI, might both entrench and disrupt these hierarchies. The conversation explores the paradox of meritocracy, the illusions of self-anointment in today’s digital culture and the future of work as AI accelerates change. If you’ve ever wondered why some ideas, people, or companies get chosen while others languish (or even how you go to where you are), this conversation will challenge you to see the hidden operating system behind everyday decisions. Enjoy the conversation...
(00:00) - Introduction to Toby Stuart. (01:50) - Understanding Anointed and Social Status. (04:40) - The Necessity and Corrosiveness of Status. (08:54) - Blurbs, Status, and the Publishing Industry. (12:40) - The Role of Association in Anointment. (15:29) - Breaking into New Fields and Status Transfer. (19:44) - Meritocracy and the Role of AI. (27:12) - AI's Impact on Status and Society. (31:38) - The Impact of AI on Status and Credentials. (34:46) - Evaluating Human Contribution in the Age of AI. (39:17) - The Future of AI Regulation and Power Dynamics. (45:29) - Self-Anointed Status in a Digital World. (51:25) - Reflections on Status and Personal Growth.
Thinking With Mitch Joel 
