Chris Wray & America's Unwinding (with George Packer)
Dec 12, 2024
auto_awesome
George Packer, a staff writer at The Atlantic known for his sharp analysis of American politics, delves into the state of democracy in the face of the upcoming 2024 election. He discusses troubling trends in voter behavior and the implications for the Democratic Party. Packer raises concerns about the misuse of power in political investigations and ponders the chilling prospect of Trump targeting January 6 Committee members. The conversation also touches on the shifting identity of the Democratic Party and the dangers of reactionary politics.
The 2024 election highlights the rise of reactionary politics, with candidates gaining traction by openly criticizing America's state, suggesting a cultural shift.
George Packer argues that the Democratic Party must adapt its strategies in response to changing voter demographics, particularly among Latino and Black voters.
The erosion of political norms, illustrated by past actions of Donald Trump, presents significant challenges for future administrations navigating contemporary politics.
Deep dives
Reactionary Politics and Its Rise
The 2024 election has highlighted the emergence of reactionary politics in the United States, especially among certain voter demographics. This shift indicates a significant change in political discourse, where candidates can gain traction by openly criticizing the state of the nation. For example, George Packer notes that a candidate can win by declaring the country 'trash,' suggesting a growing acceptance of populist rhetoric that challenges traditional political norms. This trend represents a departure from previously held political ideals, marking a turning point in American political dynamics.
Democratic Delusions Dispelled
Packer argues that the Democratic Party's previous beliefs about demographic destiny and electoral success have been shattered. He emphasizes the surprising support for Trump among Latino voters and a significant portion of Black men, which contradicts long-held assumptions about electoral demographics. The election results signal that simplistic views of voter alignment based on race or ethnicity no longer hold true, suggesting that Democrats must adapt their strategies to engage and persuade a more diverse electorate. This insight underscores the necessity for political parties to go beyond demographic projections and engage with voters on a deeper level.
The Evolution of Political Norms
The discussion pivots to how past political norms have been eroded, particularly through the actions of former President Donald Trump. Packer reflects on the historical significance of previous norms, such as the ten-year rule for FBI directors, and how these norms have been upended in contemporary politics. The firing of FBI directors, including James Comey and Chris Wray, demonstrates how Trump's approach has diluted standards that were once respected in Washington. This erosion poses challenges for future administrations, regardless of party affiliation, as they navigate a post-Trump political landscape that lacks established guidelines.
The Clash Between Populism and Elitism
The podcast highlights the ongoing conflict between economic elites and cultural elites as pivotal in shaping political behavior in the U.S. Republicans leverage the resentment of working-class voters against perceived cultural elites, while Democrats command the support of educated professionals. This schism complicates the political landscape, especially as both parties vie for the allegiance of disillusioned voters. Packer illustrates this tension by contrasting how both parties perceive and utilize elite status to their advantage, shaping voter sentiments around issues of identity and economic well-being.
Reimagining Political Strategies
Listeners are presented with a potential new approach for the Democratic Party to reconnect with working-class voters. Packer points to successful candidates who focus on addressing the economic concerns of their constituents rather than engaging in divisive cultural issues. For instance, Chris Deluzio's emphasis on corporate accountability resonates with voters who feel neglected by traditional political narratives. This strategy suggests that a pivot toward populism rooted in economic realities could be key for Democrats aiming to reclaim support among the working class.
George Packer is a staff writer at The Atlantic. Packer joins Preet to discuss his latest article, The End of Democratic Delusions, and what the 2024 election reveals about the future of American democracy and the Democratic party.
Plus, could Donald Trump have members of the Jan 6 Committee arrested? And, what will Kash Patel’s appointment as FBI Director mean for the role’s 10-year term?
For show notes and a transcript of the episode head to: https://cafe.com/stay-tuned/the-pendulum-always-swings-back-with-george-packer/
Have a question for Preet? Ask @PreetBharara on Threads, or Twitter with the hashtag #AskPreet. Email us at staytuned@cafe.com, or call 669-247-7338 to leave a voicemail.
Stay Tuned with Preet is brought to you by CAFE and the Vox Media Podcast Network.