David Cole, former legal director of the ACLU and law professor, dives into how America is gearing up for Trump's potential second term. He discusses effective strategies like litigation and grassroots mobilization to protect civil liberties. Cole emphasizes the importance of historical awareness in navigating today's political landscape and highlights the roles of community engagement and local activism. The conversation offers a thought-provoking look at how checks and balances can serve as vital guardrails for democracy amidst rising tensions.
Civic engagement and grassroots mobilization are vital tools for citizens to resist authoritarianism and protect democratic values.
The resilience of American governance's checks and balances provides a basis for hope against potential abuses of power in Trump's second term.
Deep dives
Concerns Over Trump's Administration
The podcast delves into the unsettling atmosphere surrounding the Trump administration, particularly related to the recent cabinet appointments. There are significant worries regarding the radical shifts in policy and the character of appointees, underpinned by a sense of exhaustion among citizens and lawmakers alike. This sentiment reflects a feeling of fatigue towards political oscillation and uncertainty about the administration's intentions, such as revenge against adversaries and the potential for mass deportations. Host Susan Glasser emphasizes the importance of acknowledging these developments and preparing for the implications they may have for American life in the coming years.
Navigating Emotional Survival
Participants discuss the various emotional strategies that individuals are employing to cope with the stress of the new political climate, particularly among government workers and young idealists. Some individuals are considering whether to stay in their positions, weighing the choice between effecting change from within or exiting entirely as a form of protest. The conversation highlights a dichotomy between 'engagers,' who advocate for normality in political transitions, and those advocating for disconnection from what they perceive as a chaotic system. This internal conflict showcases a broader societal struggle of how to manage engagement with a system that feels increasingly hostile to progressive values.
Checks and Balances Amidst Fear
The group reflects on the importance of institutional checks and balances in countering potential overreach by the Trump administration. Although there are fears among previously vocal critics regarding partisan retaliation, there is also recognition that the foundational structure of American governance is resilient. The conversation points to the recent rejection of controversial appointees, like Matt Gaetz, as a sign that some Republican senators are willing to impose limits on extreme elements within their party. This underscores the idea that while the environment may feel oppressive, mechanisms for resistance and accountability still exist.
Mobilization and Future Engagement
The podcast emphasizes the imperative of civic engagement and grassroots mobilization as fundamental tools for citizens to push back against the prevailing political climate. Host Evan Osnos discusses how the public is encouraged to use their voices, whether through protests or local advocacy, to safeguard democratic values and resist authoritarian impulses. Additionally, the conversation highlights the role of diverse coalitions, including legal, activist, and civic organizations, in providing avenues for citizens to act. As individuals contemplate their responses to ongoing political turmoil, the message is clear: active participation remains crucial to maintaining a robust democracy.
The Washington Roundtable discusses how people in D.C. and across the country are preparing themselves for Donald Trump’s second Presidency, and what tools citizens have to protect their rights and push back on abuses of power. The American Civil Liberties Union has called attention to the strategies of litigation, legislation, and mobilization—strategies that are proven to work. David Cole, a former legal director of the A.C.L.U. and a professor of law and public policy at Georgetown University, joins Susan B. Glasser, Jane Mayer, and Evan Osnos to discuss the checks and balances that exist as guardrails in government and civil society, and how those may be utilized in the coming four years.
To discover more podcasts from The New Yorker, visit newyorker.com/podcasts. To send in feedback on this episode, write to themail@newyorker.com with “The Political Scene” in the subject line.