Data Over Dogma Episode 103: The Pastor Skeptic
Mar 24, 2025
Jeremy Steele, a Pastor and self-described 'deep skeptic,' shares his journey of building an online congregation for those feeling disconnected from traditional churches. He discusses the emotional challenges of reconciling skepticism with faith and the importance of community for those deconstructing their beliefs. The conversation highlights the role of data in shaping personal convictions and the evolving landscape of spirituality, shedding light on the need for authenticity and support in navigating faith and uncertainty.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Internalized Homophobia
- Jeremy Steele recounts growing up gay in the evangelical South, where being anything but straight was considered a "temptation".
- He shares an anecdote about a classmate disappearing after confiding his struggles with homosexuality, highlighting the community's intolerance.
The Normalcy of Dogma
- Steele explains that internalized homophobia and dogma feel normal until challenged.
- He discusses his path to seminary despite internal conflict, driven by a childhood calling.
Empathetic Listening
- Acknowledge others' pain without trying to fix it, simply offering empathetic support.
- Steele emphasizes that sometimes people need a comforting presence more than solutions.
