In this conversation, Andrew Sage, a cultural analyst, joins to explore the fascinating ways the world can be divided, examining historical and contemporary perspectives. They tackle the binaries of civilization versus barbarism, critiquing how these narratives shape global perceptions. The discussion ranges from the historical context of nationalism to the implications of Cold War classifications. They also delve into the complexities of colonialism and its ongoing impact on migration and socio-economic disparities, urging a reevaluation of societal divisions.
49:55
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
question_answer ANECDOTE
Burmese Fighters Reject "Primitive" Label
James Stout shares how young Burmese fighters rejected the state's 'primitive' label on ethnic revolutionary groups.
They found solidarity and recognized shared goals with those living outside the state.
insights INSIGHT
Civilized vs. Barbarian Binary Dynamics
The "civilized vs. barbarian" binary was historically used by Rome to assert superiority.
Romans incorporated 'barbarians' later as useful soldiers and labor, showing the binary's complexity.
insights INSIGHT
Orientalism's Racialized Division
The Orient vs. Occident binary racializes geographical and cultural divisions explicitly.
The West is often coded as the 'white world,' while the East is seen as exotic and inferior.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
James C. Scott's "The Art of Not Being Governed" explores the history and strategies of marginalized communities who have resisted state control. The book focuses on the Zomia region of Southeast Asia, a mountainous area where diverse ethnic groups have maintained their autonomy by evading state power. Scott examines how these communities have used their knowledge of the terrain and their social organization to resist state-led projects and maintain their independence. The book challenges conventional understandings of state power and highlights the resilience of marginalized communities in the face of oppression. Scott's work offers valuable insights into the dynamics of power, resistance, and state formation.
Imagined Communities
Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism
Benedict Anderson
In 'Imagined Communities,' Benedict Anderson examines the historical rise and development of nationalism. He argues that nations are not ancient communities but rather modern constructs, imagined by their members as a shared, limited, and sovereign community. Anderson traces the emergence of nationalism to the Americas in the 18th and 19th centuries, where creole elites and the spread of print capitalism played crucial roles. He also discusses how nationalism filled the void left by the decline of religious communities and how it was shaped by factors such as mass vernacular literacy, the abolition of divine right monarchies, and the standardization of national calendars, clocks, and languages. The book is influential in social sciences and has been widely cited and translated into more than thirty languages.
The Clash of Civilizations?
Samuel P. Huntington
In this book, Huntington expands on his 1993 thesis that future wars will be fought not between countries, but between cultures. He argues that the primary axis of conflict in the post–Cold War world will be along cultural lines, with different civilizations, such as Western, Islamic, and Sinic, becoming increasingly significant in analyzing potential conflicts. Huntington also discusses the shift of economic, military, and political power from the West to other civilizations and critiques the Western belief in the universality of its values and political systems[4][5][1].
Orientalism
Edward Said
In 'Orientalism,' Edward Said critiques the Western construction of the Orient as a place of mystery and exoticism. He argues that Orientalism, as a discipline and worldview, is inherently tied to European imperialism and serves as a powerful instrument of domination. Said examines how Western literature, academia, and politics have perpetuated colonialism and imperialism by creating and reinforcing stereotypes and myths about the East. He traces the development of Orientalism from its roots in the 18th century to its contemporary implications, emphasizing the intimate relationship between knowledge and power and the need to challenge these dominant discourses[1][3][5].
James and Andrew discuss different ways of splitting up the world, and what they tell us about the way their proponents see the world.